if this be so, there was no Jewish vote in the sense of Jews voting for a special Jewish interest. But what is meant by a Jewish vote is that the Jewish voters have certain inclinations which lead them to vote as a ponderable body for this or that candidate; that if a Jew is nominated, and all other things are equal, they vote for him; that where a Jew is nominated who is not a good Jew, all other things being equal, they vote in a body against him; that, as in the recent election in the vote for Mr. MacAneny, where a candidate is eminently superior, they exercise the greatest intelligence, and the vote cast for him is relatively larger than in other districts where the supposed intelligent vote comes from. Furthermore, a Jewish interest may be presumed to be back of a decided swing of Jewish votes. The fact that the interest does not appear on the surface is not proof that there is none. There must be a Jewish interest where thousands of Jews vote as a body. But why should Jews repudiate the suggestion that there is a Jewish vote? There is strength in such a possibility, while it is certainly no advantage to Jews as citizens to be a negligible quantity in the elections. Should any clear-cut interest appear, would it not be desirable to have the Jews as a body conscious of that interest? And, in fact, do not the very men who will not admit the existence of a Jewish vote as practical men rely upon such a vote? Why these meaningless apologies?
National Y. M. H. A. Federation.
The Federation of Young Men's Associations formed in New York on November 2nd, is worth more than a passing notice. These associations of Jewish young men have become surprisingly numerous. Whether this is due to their exclusion from Christian associations with similar activities, or to an inward compulsion to engage in specifically Jewish work, does not really matter. The Young Men's Hebrew Association is here to stay. It is going to be not only thoroughly American, but its Americanism is to be colored by Jewish motives
and qualities. And a national federation was inevitable. There must be a clearing-house for the local experiences in this department of social endeavor. The smaller associations must have the advice and co-operation of the larger ones. Certain features can best be maintained by co-operative endeavor. A Iyceum bureau specially fitted for young men thus becomes a possibility. The issuance of travelling membership cards will result in establishing for the young man who removes to another city an immediate social connection, similar, in many waysto the one which he has left. Is it too much to say that the growth of these associations is due to the Menorah societies and the Zionist literary clubs and circles? These Jewish young men have little or no knowledge of Judaism, but they are inclined to be Jewish, if only some one would show them how. They are not Zionists yet, but they feel what every American knows, that in union there is strength. And in this desire to strengthen their position as Jews, we shall find our opportunity as Zionists. The New England Federation of Young Men’s Hebrew Associations gave its sympathy to Zionism and voted to contribute to the National Fund. In many sections, Zionist young men are influential members, and it maybe possible for us to exert our influence on a larger scale in the National Federation which seems to start under such good auspices. There is evident here, however, the same incomprehensible desire on the part of some people to complicate the scheme of organization to prevent a clear-cut democratic control. The same infiuences that segregated the New York Khillah’s Bureau of Education so that public opinion could have no influence on its policies, are evident in the organization of the National Federation of Y. M. H. Ass’ns. The funds are “safely” trustified. The trustees of the funds are to have independent corporate rights. Is this done to control the policy of the Federation? But we have no fear that the splendid young men who form the Federation will allow the destinies of the organization to be directed by an oligarchy,