The Maccabaean · Vol. XXIII, No. 11 · November 1913
320printed page
scan 18 of 32
320
THE MACCABEAN

sion of the genius, we must primarily possess a free Jewish life, that should create the necessary atmosphere for the rise of the Spiritual centre. The best intellectual activities dıe in their bud for want of air to breathe, as flowers wither without the rays of the sun. It is dificult to define that Jewish life, and practically impossible, since it is yet to be seen in what way will it develop, but whatever form it will assume ıt wıll be normal, and out of this natural life, the forces that will rejuvenate Judaism willbe drawn. The spiritual centre, therefore, presupposes an economic and social centre, in all its various hues and colors. The size of this centre is indefinite. It is understood that it must be broad enough to form a basis for a regenerated and expanded Jewish spirit that in its turn should serve as the heart for the Jews of the Diaspora. It must therefore, reflect all tendencies and directions of life. This leads us directly to Zionism.

The answer outlined in the foregoing pages is what is known as spiritual Zionism advocated by the famous Hebrew essayist Ahad Haam. It was thought that there is a certain difference between spiritual Zionism and official Zionism. In reality, there is hardly a distinction, both converge at the same point in Palestine. The former does not deny the necessity of settlements, land buying, building up the industry and the rest of the things necessary for a modern life. It needs them just as much as the latter, for the spirit needs a body to be clothed with. On the other hand, official Zionism does not and cannot deny the necessity of the rejuvenation of the Hebrew soul.

If there is a difference, I should rather say it is in the origin of these two streams of the national movement, the causes that begot them. We have seen that the fons et origo of the first lies in the great plight of Judaism, of the second, in the plight of the Jews. The great mis-

ery of the eastern Jews, the wave of antisemitism that swept over Europe in the last decade of the nineteenth century, were responsible for the rise of what was called political Zionism. It came as an answer to the question, how to minimize the suffering of the Jews. I do not need to go over its history; it is well known. Suffice it to say that within the short time of its existence, it dropped a few of the legendary characteristics that it had in the beginning, and retained the eternal elements, which bring it nearer to spiritual Zionism. It is ridiculous to speak to these two streams as two parties or in any other way that points to the existence of a division. In reality, official and spiritual Zionism not only are not exclusive, or have different fields, but complete each other. It is only a little more emphasis that is placed upon one idea or another. Moreover, spiritual Zionism if understood in the right way includes practically the whole work of Zionism, for the economic and industrial centre must be first established in order to enable the spiritual centre to rise. If there is a misunderstanding it is rather on the part of political Zionists, some of whom narrow down the aim of the national movement to the mere material question, neglecting entirely its spiritual side. Were that the true and speedy solution of the infinite misery of the Jews, the work would be worth while, even at the expense of the temporarily neglect of the spiritual. But matters proved otherwise, Zionism has been crystallized and clarified into a movement which has its roots deep in history and soul of the nation. Every Zionist now knows that the movement he stands for will not cure all the wounds of the nation at one stroke and within a short time. He also knows that the Diaspora will not be abolished and that there will be a Judaism in Goluth. But he also knows at the same time that the ideal he stands for is the right road to the perpetuation of the Jewish nation.

It is this great ideal, that is the