The Maccabaean · Vol. XXIII, No. 11 · November 1913
318printed page
scan 16 of 32
318
THE MACCABÆAN

As a result it grew less tolerant, it lay claim to everyone within its sphere, and could not allow any secluded centres. The Jew, turned loose in this cultural environment, is subjected to its attractions, it surrounds him and demands its rights. If he wishes to preserve his entity in the full sense of the word, not only physical existence but spiritual and cultural, the Jew has to defend himself against a strong enemy.

Meanwhile, to make matters worse, internal disintegration went on within the house of Israel. Wherever Judaism has gone out of the Ghetto, it was at the expense of its principles and ideals. Whatever remained of the former ideals of Judaism are now only a mere semblance, and consequently not as important factors in Jewish life as they used to be. Hardly any Jew, not even the most orthodox, can claim now that the Messianic belief in the Geula, love for Palestine, has as much vividness, strength and force for him as for the Mediaeval Jew. There is one more point to be emphasized, viz, the extent of modern culture, that even should the Jewish culture be as strong as ever, it is still unable to cope with the external one, on account of its limited field. We have then a vicious circle; the inner force becomes weakened, the outer attack stronger, and so conditions assume a more and more grave aspect. Development is arrested, for all development requires growth, growth necessitates the assimilation of external elements unto itself in order to establish equilibrium with the environment. Judaism has performed this operation of digesting foreign elements many a time during its existence.—But it is different in modern times. At present, culture is national in its essence, and the one that is dominant claims full right to swallow everything that comes in contact with it. No original development of Judaism is possible in the Diaspora, and the grave danger then arises, of Judaism losing its internal

entity, or what is equally bad, the national unity, each Jewry in each country assuming a different color according to the external influence of the land culture.

The problem of modern Judaism resolves itself from the following phases: How to maintain Judaism in the Diaspora as a distinct entity, against the rushing tide of modern culture and how to keep the Jewry intact so that the external environment shall not tear away the best limbs. Secondly, what is most important how to receive it and develop the spirit of the nation so that it should become as it was, an active force, contributing to the perfection of the race, as well as to the sum total of human civilization. Mere maintenance is not sufficient; to continue an insipid existence without aimor purpose is hardly called living. To live, means to act, and national activity is therefore, a conditio sine qua non. Moreover, as has been pointed out already, not even mere existence can be attained without development and fruitful action. Modern culture does not know of half done things, of compromises; either full conquest or complete defeat; therefore in order to maintain ourselves, we must revive the Jewish spirit, develop Jewish culture so, that it shall be thoroughly equipped to take the field against the surrounding cultures. To be satisfied with present conditions of Judaism requires either foolhardiness or blindness. The ties that bind most of the members of the Jewry to their nation are loosened, even those who profess to be the most loyal, the orthodox Jews, are animated more by mechanism than by real burning love and zeal. The great ideal of Palestine even in its religious form, has become an impotent factor, an ideal that does not arouse people to action is only a sentiment, a mere belief without any force.

The last hundred years have hardly produced any great men for whom credit was given distinctly to us as Jews. With great sorrow