The Maccabaean · Vol. XXIII, No. 11 · November 1913
314printed page
scan 12 of 32
Facsimile · scan 12 of 32
Scan of p. 314
Text · transcribed from the scan

has two left hands instead of one; that he ever gets entangled into one of his own feet, that he would sooner carry himself askew than straight, etc, etc.

ar This is what the anti-Semites are claiming, and this is what many of us are repeating after them. At best, we plead extenuating circumstances. What wonder, we say, that we.are deficient in muscular strength and dexterity? Our thousand-year-old Ghetto confinement, we claim, has deprived us of physical exercise, and has caused our physical inefficieney. And now, we say, we certainly miss it, and it will go hard with us before we develop ouı strength again.. Yes, it is with hate that the anti-Semites are contemplating us, and it is their animosity that makes them ascribe a ridiculously wrong meaning to the facts, and to make generalizations out of them.

True, too many Jews are of poor physical deportment. But that is in no way natural with them. It is but the result of a lack of physical training. And in this respect the Jew in no way differs from the so-called. Arian. ' Whoever can, let: him but observe things in barrack-yards and on drilling-grounds. And he will observe quickly enough that the Jew taken, say. from the shop counter or from the shoemaker’s bench in no way differs in appearance from his Gentile brother-in-trade. Then, I heard it from drillmasters that the Gentile day-laborer, apprentice ana clerk are much harder to train thaı young Jews of the same callings. The latter, they said, are more docile and are quicker to learn than even the Gentile country lads and farmhands who certainly had all the possibilities of developing muscular dexterity. And these were drillmasters who could not be suspected of any bias; not even of a desire to do us simple justice. These scarecrow caricatures of Jewish soldiers with which some humorists are trying to regale the Jewish and non-Jewish anti-Semites are not taken from actual life. These cartoons are

naught but friendly and well meant raillery. If there be any moral underlying these caricatures, it is the newly drafted warrior, Jew or non-Jew. And there is certainly nothing specifically Jewish about these pictures of Falstaffian soldiery.

As to stature and stateliness, the Jew, comparatively speaking, leaves much to be desired; particularly in countries with a predominating Slavonic or Germanic populace; much less so in Romanic countries. There was a time when I entertained the possibly groundless notion that the rather short stature of the Jew represents a symptom of degeneracy. But of late I became somewhat shaky in this belief. For it is impossible to arrive at any scientifically based conclusions while the ethnography and anthropology of the Jewish race are as yet unexplored domains. And we cannot tell positively whether Jews were a taller race originally, and diminished in stature on account of unfavorable surroundings, or else were originally a short-statured race. Of excavations which could shed some light on this question I know nothing. And such excavations, to be of any real value, would have to be above any doubt that it is Jewish graves that are dealt with. Ana the proofs from ancient history are equally undecisive. The carvings on Egyptian and Assyrian monuments do not show that the Jews appeared to the artists any smaller than the non-Jews. Then there were Jews in Rome who used to exhibit themselves, for a fee, on account of their gigantic stature. On the other hand. some remarks in the Bible would lead us to the conclusion that certain neighboring tribes did seen, to the Jews in Palestine very much above their own size. One needs only read of the “Sons of Enak” and of the comparative descriptions of Goliath and David.

So, either we were a small statured race originally, or else have become one in time. And it is not to be denied that, on the average, we are somewhat inferior in size to the