The Maccabaean · Vol. XXIII, No. 9 · September 1913
266printed page
scan 12 of 48
266
THE MACCABÆAN

gress was opposed by the delegates of the Poale Zion on the grounds that the establishment and maintenance of a university is incompatible with our more important work in Palestine. There is an undeniable demand in Palestine for schools, but for schools of a nature entirely different from what is comprehended in the idea of a university as provided for by the Congress.

Such a university would have to be, in order to attract students from other lands, a first-rate institution capable of vying at least with the large European and American Universities. The establishment and maintenance of such a university would mean the expenditure of immense sums of money, a great draught upon our resources, to say nothing of the perpetual and active concentration for its welfare which it will necessitate on our part. Nothing less than a keen demand for it in our colonization work should actuate us to such a step; and its promises should be big, big enough to warrent the outlay of so much money and energy.

But what is the character of our Palestinian demand for schools? Do we need lawyers? doctors? doctors of philosophy? The questions need hardly be answered. It is very simple that high culture must only be the fruit of a developed environment which is the only natural recipient of a high refinement. A country which is undeveloped industrially and agriculturally needs schools that will make good farmers, hardy and industrious workers, efficient tradesmen, men of energy and a will to do hard work. The presence of a university such as is provided for by the 'Congress would be nothing less than a distraction, to say nothing of its practical uselessness.

Poale Zionists are not opposed to a university in Palestine. They join every true Zionist in the hope that some day Palestine will be the greatest center of culture. But since there is at present no demand in Palestine for a university and since the establishment of one can result in no benefit to our work we oppose strongly this provision of the Congress and hope that all conscientious Zionists will join us in our endeavor to pre-

vent what might prove a misuse of our energies.

Colonization Work.

The reports of the progress of our Colonization work showed that our progress has not been what it should have been. The leaders of Poale Zion believe that certain modifications in the Organization policy would lead to more gratifying results.

The Organization should depart from its policy of focussing its energies upon the promotion of the interests of individual colonists and pay more attention to the communal aspects of its colonial problems. Already we can perceive certain evils on the horizon of our Palestinian work, perceptions derived from an observation of other societies in which similar situations produced such evils.

The logical result of our present policy of promoting individual interests will lead to the perpetuation in the spirit of the colonists the right to individual increase at any cost. Already Jewish employers are finding it profitable to employ Arabs in preference to Jews, for the former whose necessities are small can work at a much lower price than the latter whose needs are greater. The evil which would result from an enhancement of this state of affairs would be twofold: since Arabs are willing to work at a small price they would be hired in large numbers in preference to Jews, a practice which would mean a check to Jewish settlement; an Arabian proletariat would arise, and that would mean a solid anti-Jewish spirit in Palestine.

We Zionists should consider it a sacred duty to do our work so that our nation shall not through our blundering become involved in petty national strifes. To create an Aabian proletariat is to create a solid opposition. This is the logical result of any system of exploitation. We see what such a system has done for America and the nations of Europe. We can avoid the bitter class wars which now pierce the lives of these nations.

The Zionist organization ought however toil for the advancement and increase of those industrial groups extant