would mean a disastrous setback for the future of the Jewish people in Palestine. That an institution maintained or assisted by the Zionist movement should lend itself, however innocent its intent, to the increase of a foreign sphere of influence in Syria, we cannot but regard as gravely prejudicial to the Zionist cause and the Jewish future in Palestine.
All the more perverse is such an action in the present circumstances when, happily, the indications are not wanting that the Otoman Power has begun to recognize the solid advantages that the Empire would gain by the encouragement of true Zionist efforts in Palestine. The Zionists are introducing large capital into the country and are prepared to develop its agricultural and industrial potentialities. Zionist success must inevitably redound to the wealth and the welfare of the Empire at large. For it should be emphasized that the endeavors of the Zionist organization are directed not to the exploitation of the country for the benefit of foreign corporations and governments, but rather to the development of a patriotic Jewish community that shall prove beneficent in every way to the Empire of which it must form an integral part.
On the other hand, in return for these advantages to the Ottoman Empire, and, at the same time, to raise these Zionist efforts to their highest efficiency, we must require upon the basis of the new democracy in the Empire, that the Zionist establishment in Palestine be granted that measure of autonomy which shall be sufficient for the fruitful prosecution of our agricultural and industrial projects and shall give ample scope to our revived Jewish life and culture; in short, we desire to develop a Jewish polity in Palestine, but a polity that shall be a permanent and beneficent Jewish province in the Ottoman Empire. This we hold to be the Zionist political ideal.
To facilitate this course, which, we repeat, is clearly not less advantageous to the Ottoman Empire at large than to Palestine in especial, we believe it essential that the Zionist organization be accorded an official status in Constantinople and be recognized by the Imperial government as the political representative of the Jewish people; that all
Jewish institutions and enterprises in Palestine be placed formally by the Emperial Government under the direction of the Zionist Organization and that, en revanche, the Zionist Organization be made responsible to the Imperial Government for the administration of these Jewish institutions and enterprises. Thereby, we believe, will be removed every color of excuse for the claims of foreign.governments to protect Jewish interests in Palestine; claims so obviously anomalous when it is once recognized that Jewish interests in Palestine are first and last Ottoman interests and not the interests of any foreign oower whatsoever.
The time is ripe for the open and official recognition of this close community of interests between the Ottoman Government and the Zionist organization. The conclusion of a formal understanding between these two parties, involving a .mutual recognition of common interests, and containing definite provisions for the representative administration of the Jewish settlement in Palestine, would, we feel certain, give an extraordinary impetus to the healthy development of the country, both economic and cultural; would remove the grounds of foreign pretensions; and would, above all, by an enduring and beneficent alliance, draw closer the ties of blood, and cement the bonds of hereditary friendship, between the Turkish and the Jewish peoples.
These considerations we respectfully submit to the Actions Comite and to the delegates to the forthcoming Zionist Congress and we urge the Congress to formulate these principles in specification of the Basle program.
N. FRIEDMAN, M.D. JACOB DE HAAS ADOLPH HUBBARD HENRY HURWITZ, M.A. JULIUS MEYER, Boston, Mass. HORACE M. KALLEN, Ph.D. Madison, Wis. BORIS KAZMAN Battle Creek, Mich. HENRY M. SHEFFER, Ph.D. Minneapolis, Minn.
