The Maccabaean · Vol. XXIII, No. 7 · July 1913
193printed page
scan 3 of 32
Facsimile · scan 3 of 32
Scan of p. 193
Text · transcribed from the scan

SUNDAY AFTERNOON'S SESSION

Harry Friedenwald, took his seat on the platform upon the opening of the afternoon session.

Mr. Goldberg read a letter of greeting to the convention in Hebrew from Dr. Mossessohn of Jaffa.

Mr. Kahanowitz moved that the letter be printed in its original form in the Yiddish Folk. It was agreed that this be done.

The following telegrams of greeting to the Convention were read:

Canadian Zionist Federation, Montreal, Can., Mr. Clarence I. de Sola, Prest.

Directors of the Yiddish Folk, New York.

Mrs. Isadore Natkin, Chicago, Ill. Cleveland Zionist Society.

Zionist Council of Pittsburg, Pa.

Zionist Association of Greater New York.

Rabbi H. Pereira Mendes, New York. Mr. and Mrs. I. L. Borushak, St. Louis. Mo.

Zionist Council of St. Louis, Mo.

Ahavas Zion. Grand Forks. N. D.

Mr. and Mrs. Henry Jackson, Pittsburg, Pa.

Knights of Zion, Chicago, Ill. Max Shulman, President.

Zionist Council of Pittsburg (National Fund Telegram).

Agudath Zion, San Francisco, Cal.

Sisters of Zion of Pittsburg, Pa.

Max Shulman, Chicago, Ill.

Order Sons of Zion, New York City.

Achieber, New York.

Hatchiah Camp No. 43, Order Knights of Zion, Chicago, Ill.

Abraham, George and Rachel Lubarsky, Arverne, L. I.

Agudath Degel Zion, Brownsville, N. Y.

Prof. Kallen then delivered an informal address on the subject of the need of a Jewish National University in Palestine. He stated, in substance, that aur conception of a national university being uncertain, it renders the project a rather dangerous one for us to undertake. We Jews in America are asked to create abroad an institution for higher education in terms of our money, of course, for persons who have not had a genuine Jewish education or otherwise. I have a sort of conception that the notion of a university in Palestine is formulated by persons who are either ignorant of the history of education or who are completely unaware of the relation of education to the community and the needs of the community. Now, there are always two forces that determine educational methods and the field of education. One of these forces is tradition. A great deal of education is determined by educational tradition. The other force is

economical pressure. In the last 15 years the subject of economics, or political economy, the art of getting rich, so to speak, has been a most prominent and weighty subject in a university curriculum. So called cultural subjects have fallen completely in the background, and the interest in education in this country, in Germany, England, &c. has been along the line of mentally equipping persons to make a living rather than properly fitting them for ceitizenship. The kind of subjects young men’ who find it extremely difficult to enter the universities of Germany anı Russia are likely to demand are practical subjects determined by modern needs, such as engineering, law, chemistry, &c. and it is questionable if they will consent to use their learnning, if after such a university is established, in the country where they have acquirea same. Prof. Kallen stated he was not in accord with the idea of establishing a university in Palestine until that country has a national life, and just now there is no national life in Palestine. It is advisable, therefore, to hesitate before recommending the establishment of a Jewish National University m Palestine. Get a nation first; get Palestie for the Jew. I am of the opinion that it is better for the Convention to take no position in this matter until we have adequate information; until the specifications of the nature of this university are given out and until we are able to judge whether such a university will be national or not.

Prof. Kallen’s remarks gave rise to a lengthy and interesting debate.

Mr. Kazman declared that it would be better for the Zionists to put more effort in Zionism at present in the form of a university to foster the Zionist idea.

Mr. Abram Goldberg stated that a Jewish university is one of our greatest needs and took issue with Prof. Kallen on his stand in the matter.

A resolution was then proposed, as follows: “Resolved that the Convention favorably recommend the proposal for a Jewish University in Jerusalem”.

Mr. Cowen stated that such a university would place on Palestine a larger burden than it can carry. Palestine is as yet undeveloped and its Jewish population is still small. The number of people living in Palestine who are able to support themselves is small. It is still necessary for them to rely upon their brethren outside of Palestinee Purely Zionist work means the development of the national feeling and the building up of a Jewish nation. Too many objects dissipate the energy of the Zionists. Let us separate it from the Zionist work. Of course, the Zionists are interested in such an institution, but we must not place the burden of the work involving its establishment on