The Maccabaean · Vol. XXIII, No. 7 · July 1913
209printed page
scan 19 of 32
THE MACCABÆAN
209

Mr. Goldberg pronounced the resolution as not practical. The Kehillah is not a Zionist organization, and even if we accepted the resolution it could not be carried out.

Mr. Hankin urged that efforts be made to introduce Young Judea in the Kehillah.

Judge Bregstone was of the opinion that the matter should be considered only by those familiar with the situation.

Upon motion of Mr. Kahanowitz, the resolution was referred to the Executive Committee.

A prolonged and interesting debate ensued on the following resolution:

Be it resolved that the Convention urge upon the 11th Congress about to meet in Vienna that it is essential that efforts be made to obtain public recognition of the Zionist Organization as a political entity representative of the Jewish people.

Mr. Kahanowitz pointed out that this resolution was the same as that laid on the table at a previous session, and moved to lay it on the table.

Mr. Rosenblatt raised the point of order that this was hardly fair to the chairman of the Resolutions Committee and was of the opinion that in its amended form the resolution should be acceptable to everyone.

Prof. Kallen declared that the Convention would be stultifying itself if it failed to face the question fairly. This resolution involves an essential principle of Zionist organization, and to table this question at this moment is simply to say that we will work with our eyes shut. It is a matter of necessity to ourselves to fight this proposition out and to vote for or against it.

Mr. Kahanowitz withdrew his motion to lay the resolution on the table.

Mr. Cowen in explaining the Resolution to the delegates, stated that the original resolution submitted by the Executive Committee (No. 3 in THE MACCABÆAN) called for the appreciation and approval of the work of the Actions Committee. We are confronted with a peculiar situation. As a Zionist organization we represent a definite fighting force for recognition of the Zionist organization and the Jewish people as a definite political entity. In view of the present state of affairs in the Turkish Empire this is a great opportunity for us to get concessions and get it with very little money. We are opposed to Palestinism, but we wish to lay emphasis on Zionism, and in our political negotiations we should act for the whole people—as a nation, and as a political entity. We Jews wish to be recognized as a political entity. We desire to have the institutions in Palestine recognized as institutions belonging to the Jewish state, as belonging to us—not as private institutions but as National institutions. At this crucial moment we want to be recognized as a political entity. We must maintain and keep alive the political ideal.

Dr. Levinson asked if the time was ripe

for us to go out and tell the Turkish Government that we are a political entity, that we are a state. He expressed the opinion that we are not prepared for it.

Judge Bregstone stated that the original resolution gave him the impression that we left off pactical Zionism and took up political Zionism. The resolution as now framed works for both practical and political Zionism.

Rabbi Ebin opposed the resolution, and stated that it would be part of wisdom to let the Actions Committee decide the issue.

The debate on this resolution threatened to become interminable, as many more delegates expressed a desire to speak on the resolution, and in order to curtail futher discussion, the chairman limited the discussion to two speakers, one in the affirmative and one in the negative.

Mr. de Haas, for the affirmative side, stated that this resolution will establish peace in the Zionist movement. Under the present state of affairs the various Zionist institutions do not belong to us, but are accredited to different countries. We want them to belong to us, and the result which we desire to bring about finds expression in this resolution.

Rabbi Ebin, for the negative side, expressed himself as being rather dubious concerning our readiness to go out in the world and proclaim that we are a political entity, and as to the advisibility of such a step being taken. We must not do anything that will harm our organization and endanger our future existence.

Mr. Avner also raised the question as to whether the resolution would hurt our standing.

Mr. Cowen declared that we should let the world realize that there is a united force behind our efforts, and we should not hide and be afraid to proclaim our intentions.

On a standing vote, the resolution was passed 25 to 13.

The following resolution was carried without debate:

"That the Convention recommend that the Actions Committee take steps to further the sale of the shares of the Jewish Colonial Trust in order to increase its activity."

The following resolution was referred to the Executive Committee for consideration:

"That the Convention instruct the Executive Committee to arrange for a lecture course of all the cities in which there are Zionist societies, and where communities desire it. This course to be self sustaining and the course to consist of not less than 4 lectures."

The following resolution was adopted without debate:

"Resolved that the Actions Committee be requested to make the recommendation that the principle be laid down that all Zionists tax themselves one-half of one percent of their annual incomes for the benefit of the Jewish National Fund."

The following Resolution was next