The Maccabaean · Vol. XXIII, No. 7 · July 1913
200printed page
scan 10 of 32
200
THE MACCABÆAN

H. M. Kallen, chairman; N. H. Ebin, H. L. Meites, Samuel Amdursky, I. Kahanowitz.

hanowitz. These portions of the Executive Committee's report recommended, as above, to be eliminated, read as follows:

Young Judea

“It seems unfortunate, however, tnat such a virile organization should have to depend for financial support on the Federation of American Zionists, which has so many other calls for activity. It has been the opinion of your Executive Committee tnat such reliance on the older Zionists was unnecessary and even harmful. It should be possible to interest the parents of the children, who profit so much from junior Zionism, to take an active part in its business management. The expense of Young Judea, including the issuance of its montnly magazine, is very small, and strong efforts should be made to place it on a self-sustaining basis. We have here an organization which is not superimposed by the charities and philanthropies of the great, but is the outcome of tne Jewish national longings in Jewish children. Such an institution should obtain support without a direct financial dependence on the larger organization.”

Zionism in Universities

“The ‘Menoran’ movement that has already assumed an importance beyond the fondest expectations of its organizers, was founded, encouraged and supported, almost exclusively, by Zionists. Its leaders to-day are convinced adherents of our cause. We can trust to the independence of our American Jewish youth who will refuse to be bound by old, worn-out theories of 'cos- mopolitanism’ on the one side, and a misconstrued ‘patriotism’ on the other, and wno will accept the Menorah training as the natural stepping-stone to Jewish nationalism.”

Mr. Cowen moved the acceptance of the committee’s report. This was seconded.

A Louisville delegate protested against the attitude of the Committee in recommending that the Zionist disclaim any credit for creating Zionist sentiment in the universities and added that it seems strange that we should be afraid to say that we wish to help the Menorah, He added that we should be proud of what we stand for and urged the delegates not to vote on tnis recommendation which means that we are to keep absolutely quiet and be afraid to assume credit for any Zionistic work performed in universities for fear that someone will not join us. He expressed the opinion that only a few of the Menorah members will not come with us.

Prof. Kallen admitted that a great many of the Menorah societies were organized by members who are Zionists, but these individuals did not act in any official capacity.

They acted primarily as members of universities who were interested purely in scholarly questions concerning the history of the Jews. The constitution of the Menorah is based along lines purely scholarly and academic. It means that Zionism will be discussed in every Menorah society as a phase of Jewish life, but that other questions will also be discussed. The Federation is in no way responsible for the Menorah. The claim for responsibility or credit is a mistake. The Committee thoroughly discussed this matter and made its recommendation after a fair consideration of the nmıestinn

Mr. Pearlstein opposed Prof. Kallen's views and stated that the Menorah will be an influence for Zionism when it gets on its feet, and it should be regarded by the Convention as an offshoot of Zionist propaganda.

Madame Pevsner concurred in Prof. Kallen's views and stated that the Menorah should be kept out of official Zionist influence

Dr. Levinson stated that while he was never in favor of hiding our indentity, in this case he agreed with Dr. Kallen. To support his contention, he mentioned a society (Z. B. T.) organized 14 years ago on Zionist principles. Nothing but Zionism was proclaimed, and as a result several years later Zionism was cut out of their program.

Miss Szold contended that the question involved in Madame Pevsner’s report as to carrying on indirect propaganda for Zionism and that involved in giving the Zionist organization credit for introducing Zionism in the Menorah societies are two separate issues, and deemed it the part of prudence not to claim credit for introducing Zionism in the Menorah except in a general form.

The question of accepting the Committee's report was put to a vote and was carried.

The session then adjourned.

MONDAY AFTERNOON'S SESSION

Announcement was made that Rabbi Meyer Waxman, of Brooklyn, N.Y., had been awarded the first honors in the Honrietta Szold Prize for 1913—1914, for an cssav on the suject: “The Importance of Palestine to the Jews of tne Diaspora in the past and present.”

Mr. Pearlstein submitted to the Convention report on the work and activities of the Knights of Zion during the past year, which is as follows:

The Knights of Zion

On behalf of the Executive Committee of the Knights of Zion, the Western District of the l’ederation of American Zionists, we beg to submit the following report pertainıng to the activities of the Executive, as well as the affliated societies within our territory.

Since our last Convention, we have been concentrating our efforts towards practical