political association with a National ambition might have to take the place of the present congregational institutions to save them from total annihilation. The Italian Jews are to be compared to an army corps, that is gradually being disbanded, not for lack of valor, but because there is no enemy within fighting distance. The Zionists are trying to keep this force fully organized and to prevent its disintegration, because they know that other corps of the same army are still in the midst of the battle and unable by themselves to clear the way toward success and liberty in a land of freedom. These might need the assistance of the other troops already within the lines of safety and hence the necessity of keeping their organization intact. This might furnish the explanation of the pronounced Zionist tendencies prevailing in the two conventions held in the fall of 1911 in Florence and in December, 1912 in Turin by the Italian Jewish young men."
The Attack of Joseph Cowen.
Mr. Joseph Cowen, who has been re-elected president of the English Zionist Federation, and is a director of the Jewish Colonial Trust, has made a public attack on the policies of the Actions Comite. Mr. Cowen is supposed to represent the "opposition", which is composed of Dr. Alexander Marmorek, Mr. Cowen, Mr. L. J. Greenberg, and, not so intimately, of David Wolffsohn and Dr. Nordau. But it is a question whether Mr. Cowen speaks for an organized opposition. At any rate, he is one of the voices of an opposition. We in American are not vitally interested in the personal ambition of the leaders of Europe, speaking of personal ambition in the best sense of the word. If there is any criticism of the present Actions Comite to be made, it ought to be absolutely fair and unbiassed. The administration may be a bit too timid, feeling its responsibilities too keenly. It may lack confidence in itself in view of the great dangers attendant on adventuresome enterprises. Its personnel could be strengthened, probably, with better results. But, on the whole, it is an undoubted nationalist, political and practical Comite, trying to act for the best interests of the many-sided movement. Its members are not Chovevei
Zionists, nor merely Palestinians. Mr. Cowen's criticism of this hard-working and self-sacrificing Comite is, to say the least, petty and unworthy of him. If all that he said represents all of the "opposition", the Actions Comite need fear nothing.
Mr. Cowen says that the whole administration has been left largely in the hands of paid secretaries and under- secretaries. But have the secretaries acted wisely, have they done their work well? Is it necessary that all the members remain all the time in Berlin? It must be shown that their absence from Berlin has been damaging. The fact is that during the political troubles due to the Balkan war, Mr. Sokolow was in London, Mr. Jacobson in Constantinople, Mr. Hantke in Berlin with Dr. Levin and Prof. Warburg. Mr. Sokolow was in direct communication with Berlin all the time, and Mr. Jacobson gave personal reports there every once in a while. What political opportunity has been neglected? Mr. Cowen's specifications are vague and unconvincing. The removal of the headquarters to Berlin could not have intensified any German English difficulties, for the movement has always had its headquarters in Cologne, also a German city, and Herzl made Vienna the headquarters, although Mr. Cowen now opposes the holding of the next Congress in Vienna, because it is an anti-Semitic city. Mr. Cowen's criticism of the secrecy of the Comite with regard to political negotiations is merely rhetorical, for Herzl certainly held the political secrets of the movement within a more limited circle than the present Actions Committee, as Mr. Cowen well knows. Who cares now whether Herzl was once charged with secrecy in his political work? As to the treatment of Dr. Nordau's letter to the London Times, the Actions Committee, as the responsible head of the movement, after it had for good cause vetoed the publication of that letter, had a right to limit its publication in Die Welt, in order not to give color to the impression that it was an official statement. It is indeed a pity that Die Welt found it necessary to dignify Mr. Cowen's attack with an elaborate defence.