The Maccabaean · Vol. XXIII, No. 5 · May 1913
130printed page
scan 4 of 32
Facsimile · scan 4 of 32
Scan of p. 130
Text · transcribed from the scan

advantage of the sentiment created by the visit of Mr. Sokolow. Now that all Zionists are working in harmony, and inroads have been made in various large Jewish centers into the indifferent classes, it is plain that the work of the Federation will have to be extended, and the Convention will have to take up this question in earnest. Every Zionist organization, affiliated with the Federation, with the Knights of Zion, with the Order Sons of Zion, should send as many delegates as they can to Cincinnati to participate in the deliberations. The Convention proper opens on Sunday morning, June 22. The Convention committee in Cincinnati is hard at work to provide a fitting reception to the delegates.

Zangwill Again.

MR. ZANGWILL has put his contention in a nutshell for the enlightenment of a critic. He says that if an Itoland is not now initiated, the Jewish race must either gradually disappear or remain eternally scattered. He then reverts to the Arab influence in Palestine as militating against his acceptance of that land as the Itoland, and claims that Palestine can receive only a small number of Jews. Is Mr. Zangwill not doomed to see the Jews eternally scattered or gradually disappear, being unable to find the desired Itoland? Yet he maintains his ideal, and evidently proposes to work for it. Why is not the Zionist method of obtaining a territory more desirable than Mr. Zangwill's? A good map and a good text-book on political geography will, after a brief study, convince any one, as it seems to have convinced Mr. Zangwill, that there is no territory that fits his conditions. America is a melting pot, and Texas is one of the members of the Republic. Angola is in the discard. Mesopotamia is more likely to be acquired by a migration through Palestine than by negotiations for its acquisition before one Jew is settled there. Where is the Itoland? It is yet to be discovered. Now, the Zionists may have 600,000 Arabs in Palestine as against their 100,000. But does any one believe that the Arabs in a contest for mastery in the land, are destined to overcome the Jews? The Arabs may have their local customs. Their language may be acquired by Jews, and they may not be willing to learn Hebrew, but in

the run of twenty years does any one believe that the culture of Palestine will be Arabic? We do not hold the Jews in contempt. We feel that they are the masters of Palestine when they set out to become the conquerors of the land. The historic center of the Arab people is not Palestine; it is Mecca and Medina. There is nothing that holds the Arab to Palestine. He is bound to withdraw with the pressure of the population driving him southward. He may leave behind him a few records of his residence in Palestine, but they will soon be forgotten. At any rate, it will be easier for the Jews to conquer that land than it would have been for them to take possession of East Africa, with its alien population. What is it that makes Mr. Zangwill blind to facts? The Jews are conquering a place for themselves in Palestine. A few years ago, we had eighty thousand. We now have, according to Aaron Aaronsohn, 150,000. Within a few years we shall have 250,000. The Arabs are being displaced as the land comes under cultivation. What is the use of sitting disconsolately over the map searching for a territory which does not exist, when right before his eyes Mr. Zangwill may see the building of the Itoland he has spent so many years seeking? Mr. Zangwill's genius does not entitle him to the right of being unreasonable.

The Bezalel Improved.

THE growth of the Bezalel from its beginnings in 1905 has been remarkable, and the good it has dong for the Jewish population of Jerusalem, specifically and the Jews generally must be credited to the zeal and enthusiasm of Boris Schatz, its founder. That Schatz has not been a good business manager is not to his discredit, for if he had, he might have remained in golus and entered a business career. The Bezalel had to be founded by an enthusiast. Such an enthusiast, self-sacrificing, obsessed by his idea, Schatz has been, and now that the Zionist organization has taken steps to co-ordinate the affairs of the institution, it is to be hoped that his zeal and self-sacrifice will be better regulated and the Bezalel will get the fullest benefit of his services without waste. All rumors that the Bezalel is in financial straits are far-fetched and un-