The Maccabaean · Vol. XXIII, No. 5 · May 1913
151printed page
scan 25 of 32

gained many victories. At their request the Council agreed to take part in the Palestine work and to give a Jewish education to the many orphans who are educated at the cost of the community. It is scracely credible that many Jewish orphans have been given to the care of Christian teachers and have received a purely Christian education for which the Jewish community had to pay out of the orphanage funds. All that has now been changed, But there was one thing to which the governing body of the community would not agree—the abolition of the so-called “Protectionswirthschaft” When the Council decides to erect a hospital, a synagogue or some other building, a few architects, friends of the official leaders of the community are, as a rule, entrusted with the work. The Zionists and the small opposition in the Council urged on the president to stop this practice and to entrust the work to those who could do it cheaper and better. They asked for a public competition. T'he last meeting of the Council dealt with the question of erecting a children’s hospital. The Zionists at once proposed that a public competition should beinvited, and that tHe work should not be given to any friend of the official leaders. A Jong discussion took place, which resulted in a majority for the Zionist’s motion. Thereupon, Dr. Stern, the president, and Herr Kuffner, who had opposed the motion, resigned.

Dr. Stern has been for a number of years a member and president of the Communal Council, and was considered by the Jewish Nationalists of Vienna as the incarnation of assimilation and as the greatest enemy of Zionism. He is now an old man, and having been educated on the lines of the "Aufklarung and cosmopolitanism, he is only the product of an un-Jewish and old-fashioned education. He was unable to modify all the ideas of his youth and manhood when Dr. Herzel started Zionism, and remained honestly what he was. But now that he has resigned there is a reason to believe that man will take his place who better understands the present tendencies in Judaism.

Opposition to the Zionist Administration In England.

Speaking recently in East London, Joseph Cowen, one of the supporters of the extreme view of the Herzlian Zionist pro-

gram, delivered an address in which he gave expression to the opposition of his group to the preesent administration of the Zionist organization. He deplored the secrecy that shrouded some of the work of the present leaders of the movement. Political Zionists had never excluded any practical work in Palestine from their program, he said. The real practical work done in Palestine was, so far as he knew, in the main commenced in the time of Herzl. The practical work they now desired to do was that practical work which should be good practical work. He did not believe that such work could be carried out by institutions but only by individuals on the spot putting their bone and sinew into the work. Mr. Cowen said that he was not only not satisfied with the manner they were going, but he was wholly dissatisfied with the manner in which the political work was being carried on at present. Everything was being done in secret with the result that whereas the movement was regarded in Herzl’s time with general sympathy, now it was being looked upon with suspicion and distrust. In England and in other countries, Zionism was regarded by official circles as the catspaw of Germany; a more stupid or more malicious invention had never been made. But this was the result of the work that was being thoughtlessly and heedlesly done by those in power. The suspicions aroused by the Zionist movement had become intensified—for instance, at the last Congress, when it was decided to hold the Congress in Vienna. Now they might well ask who were carryig on the movement at present.

It was a calamity to think that the whole administration was left largely in the hands of paid officials, secretaries and undersecretaries. Those were the people who were now controlling Zionism. How did these people treat Dr. Nordau’s letter which had appeared in the London Times? Fearing, as they said, to give too much prominence to a pronouncement by Dr. Nordau, the official organ of the movement, the Welt, which had now deteriorated into a party organ, cut the whole letter down to two paragraphs. The opponents of Dr. Herz! used to criticize him for the supposed secrecy of his work, But how could that compare with the mystery which now characterized the deliberations of their present leaders? The practical Zionists