The Maccabaean · Vol. XXIII, No. 3 · March 1913
67printed page
scan 5 of 32
Facsimile · scan 5 of 32
Scan of p. 67
Text · transcribed from the scan

servatives are not regarded as orthodox by the orthodoxy, whose views on Jewish traditions are radically different. They may agree that tradition should be binding, but they will not agree that any one has the authority to alter the form of religious expression. In the matter of divine worship, thousands of orthodox Jews still regard the use of English in the service as a profanation, and they will not recognize as rabbis men who are not qualified to act as judges in matters involving the dietary laws, schechitah, the laws of domestic relations, etc. There are other differences based on questionable traditions. It is clear that the progress of a conservative union may be impeded by the presence of an aggressive ultra-orthodox element. But whatever impediments may interfere with its work, the United Synagogue is a step in the right direction, for if traditional Judaism is to become a living force in American Jewish life, it must adapt itself to modern conditions.

Prejudiced Articles.

In France and the United States, there have recently appeared articles on the Jews, in which an attempt is made to create a. “scare” by showing that the Jews in these two countries are unduly powerful. M. Eugene Tavernier writes of the French Jews in the Nineteenth Century and After. He goes through the civil and military registers of France and gives figures to show that Jews are out of all proportion in control of the important offices. There are 110 Jews in the Courts of Appeal, The Council of State contains twenty Jews out of a total of 120. Two hundred and two Jews are to be found as professors of faculties and in colleges nominated by the government. The Jews monopolize the drama. They run the Parisian press; of the forty papers in Paris, there are not perhaps ten without some Jewish editors. Burton J. Hendrick writes of “The Jewish Invasion of America” in McClure’s Magozine. He declares that the Jews have conquered the clothing trades. They have completely transformed the business world. They are the greatest owners of land. The Jews are now the largest single racial element in the public schools of New York.

They are rapidly driving out of the civil service, the Irish, the Germans and the native Americans. They control the theatres, the department stores, the whisky business, the mail order trade and the trade in leaf tobacco. To the Jews in this country who are engaged in charity and philanthropy all this seems crudely exaggerated. But what surprises one is the unanimous repudiation of all this exaggeration and flattery by the Jewish press. Instead of regarding Mr. Hendrick's "story" as gross flattery, many Jewish editors have repudiated all his facts. They seem to be afraid to admit that the Jews are so generally successful. What ensues if the story were true? Success deserves credit. Does America take its hat off to failures? The fact is that if the Jews were as successful as Mr. Hendrick's sensational pen would have it, it is feared that the figures telling the story would ignite the prejudice smouldering in so many corners. We dare not bee too successful. At least, we must not appear to be.

Immigration Restriction Not Dead.

THE immigration bill providing for a literacy test was passed by both Houses and vetoed by President Taft. It went back to the Senate, where it was adopted over the President's veto by the required majority. In the House, the bill was defeated, lacking five votes from the necessary two-thirds majority. For all practical purposes, the bill is dead, but it will be brought up again in the next session of Congress. The new Secretary of Commerce, Mr. Redfield, is in favor of a literacy test, and the new Secretary of Labor, Mr. Wilson, is a labor man. President Wilson himself, while probably opposed to a literacy test, is known to be favorable to a rational exclusion of aliens not fit for entrance into this country. On all sides, it is admitted that a new bill, restricting immigration on some other basis than that of a literacy test, will have a good chance to be passed by Congress and signed by President Wilson. It will require unceasing vigilance and frank political activity to make headway against what seems to be the sentiment of the leaders of public opinion on this question.