The Maccabaean · Vol. XXIII, No. 2 · February 1913
3scan
of 32

THE MACCABAEAN

Vol. XXIII
FEBRUARY 1913
No. 2

REVIEW OF THE MONTH

Progress in Palestine

THE report that comes from Berlin of the co-operation of the Jewish Colonization Association in the purchase of a large tract of land in Palestine, is a notable event in the history of our movement. It is true that the Ika does not commit itself to anything in thus working together with the Zionist organization in Palestine. At the present time, however, this may be taken as a precedent which will stop the custodian of the Baron de Hirsch funds from declaiming against Zionist ambitions. A more tolerant and cordial feeling may be expected. While in no way subscribing to the Basle program, the Ika thus, in a manner, commits itself to a policy which includes Palestine within the radius of its operations. The Inner Actions Comite, which has been engaged in negotiations with this powerful organization for some time, deserves the congratulations of all Zionists upon its victory. The effects of this large purchase under such auspices, and with the simultaneously announced recognition of the Ottoman government, should encourage our leaders in their work, and should result at the very least in a hearty and generous financial support of our international executive committee. America ought to send its share to the Central Fund of the Comite.

Mr. Schiff’s Triple Patriotism

MR. JACOB H. SCHIFF, whose benefactions seem to be unlimited in their range, recently gave to Cornell University an endowment of $100,000 for a lectureship to promote Germanic civilization in this country. Now, Mr. Schiff has consistently opposed Zionism, among other reasons, because it is the duty of Jews in this country to be American patriots, and devotion to Zionism means a devotion to an alien

patriotism. It is strange, therefore, to hear him say, as he is reported to have said at Cornell University on February Io, “I have three nationalities embodied in me. My strongest nationality is that which I selected for myself, for which I am responsible. First, I am an American, a member of the nation I selected for myself many years ago. Then, my truest attachment is to my relations, I am not a national Jew, for the Jewish nation ceased to exist 900 years ago. But Iama Jew in religion. And I am proud of my German nationality. I am proud of this trinity of nationalities in me, not because I am less an American citizen, but because I felt it my duty to my German ancestry to select this German foundation for Cornell. I believe that the German civilization has not yet fulfilled its entire mission among the peoples of the earth.” This is clear and logical, but the question that arises is, if Mr, Schiff feels that he owes a duty to his German ancestry, and he is known to feel a duty toward his Jewish ancestry, and his devotion to American civilization and progress is also apparent in his many benefactions, why does he oppose the Zionists, who feel toward their Jewish ancestry the same zeal and devotion that he feels to-words his German ancestry? They claim but two patriotisms. He boldiy takes possession of three. Does he not admit that the Jews are a nation, when he refers to “the trinity of nationalities” in himself? The truth is that no matter what Mr. Schiff may say as to Jewish nationality, the basic nationality which has made him what he is is neither American nor German; it is obviously Jewish. And though in one breath he may assert that the Jewish nation died centuries ago, in the next breath his sub-conscious Jewish national feeling forces him, as a man who speaks from his heart, to speak as a Jew. Terminology cannot alter facts,