The Maccabaean · Vol. XXIII, No. 2 · February 1913
54printed page
scan 24 of 32
Facsimile · scan 24 of 32
Scan of p. 54
Text · transcribed from the scan

sied and objectified. Witness Heine's Jehuda Halevi, Beaconsfield's novels, and Böernes' irony.

Ar Dr A A A a As regards to distribution of Jewish intellectuality, it might be expected in view ‚of the history and education of the Jewish people that it should be wide. On the whole, it may be said the Jews possess less genius but a great distribution of talent. (12) It is very often charged against the Jew that they lack in originality because their number of geniuses is very small. But this accusation falls to the ground, taking into consideration their small number and the social disabilities preventing their education—teste Russia—“It took England two hundred years after Newton,” says Joseph Jacobs (13), “to produce a Darwin. How much more ought it to take the small, socially miserable people of Israel to produce another Spinoza?”’” In the sphere of talent the Jews predominate. The curve for Jewish skill exceeds even that of Englishmen and Scotchmen. (14) The fields are various. There is a superiority of the Jews as physicians, mathematicians, chess players, scientists, philosophers, astronomers, finan<iers, and especially, philogists. These statistical facts throw down all limitations put to the Jewish intellect, Some want to rob it of the power of abstration; others exactness. The fact that Jewish talent predominates in philosophy, chess playing, as well as in natural sciences, disproves both theories. Equally unfounded is the current theory that the Jews are especially endowed with business talent. There is no special business talent at all in existence. It is the general mental ability that is necessary for becoming a great commercial light. If Jews predominate in that field, it must be inferred that they would win also in other fields; namely, they are on a higher intellectual plane (15) which in its turn is a product of racial subjectivity together with the long process of selection,

On the emotional side the characteristics of the Jew are very distinct. The basal nature, and as the whole life-history of

tone of his emotional character is his love for the sublime. It is this trait that misled the critics from Renan to Sombart to deny emotion to the Jew. They cite in their evidence the Biblical commandments against plastic art. They failed to understand the fundamental trait of the spirit of Israel. The beautiful can be expressed in art, but the sublime, the grand, the vast, does not yield to work of clay or canvass. Here, man is overwhelmed, and amazed. He stands before the sıblime, what picture will express it What statue can contain it? Hence the lack of art with the Jew. It is not the lack of emotion but too much emotion. The sublime feeling, the intense emotion, does not find any mouthpiece for its expression but the human soul. And well did that Hebrew soul express its emotion. The Old Testament books, the Iyrics of the psalmist, the haggadah, the poems of Jehuda Halevi in mediaeval times, of Bialik and Frug in modern times, are monuments of the wonderful soul thrilline in Israel.

Being strongly subjective and constantly thrown upon himself, the emotion of the Jew is expressed in such forms of art as have to do with the inner soul. He accordingly leads in lyric poetry and music. The preference of the Jew for these arts is at once racial and historic. Racial, as has been mentioned above, and still more, it is a product of history. Where in the Ghetto could the Jew have been influenced by nature, an essential component of all plastic arts, what better mode of expression could the Jew find to the deep agonies of the soul than music, the most vibrating and touching of all arts? It is by no means to be asserted that the Jew lacks taste for the plastic arts. Israels, Libin, Antokolsky, Hirshenberg, and many others prove his ability even in those fields. It is only in speaking of a preference by the Jews for certain arts which may have an ethnic claim. Another emotional trait of the Jew is their aptitude for acting in general, and tragedy in particular. The great nervous strain, the intensity of emotion to which the Jew was subjected through his life-history has developed a power of response with bodily movements, to internal stimuli of emotion. Hence the great susceptibility of the Jew to acting. As the responses were for the most of the time of a painful

(12) Ruppin Juden der Gegenwart; Jacobs on the Distribution of Jewish Ability.

(13) Joseph Jacobs Ibid.

(14) Jacobs Loc. Cit.

(15) Ruppin Loc. Cit.