with the resolution that was subsequently adopted, except that the provision for transmitting the per capita tax direct to the Federation, and the remittance by the Federation of administrative expenses to Chicago, was subsequently altered to read that the per capita tax should be collected by the District.
The discussion on the resolution was opened with remarks by Prof. H. M. Kallen and Mr. Lipsky. Mr. Lipsky declared that he was not prepared to offer suggestions as to the plan of affiliation. He argued directly for the principle of unity in organization. Other addresses were made by Mr. Harris Horwich, Mr. Antenof, Mr. Levenson, and Mr. Shulman, and the debate was postponed to the next day.
On Sunday evening a mass-meeting which filled the hall of the Hebrew Institute, where all the sessions of the convention were held, was addressed by Governor Dunne, Prof. Kallen, Mr. Lipsky, Rabbi Saul Silber and Mr. Harris Horwich. It was said that the meeting was one of the best Zionist meetings ever held in Chicago.
On Monday, the debate on affiliation was continued. There were a large number of speakers. Quite a number felt that affiliation would have a disastrous effect on local propaganda, for the workers might lose their interest in Zionism if the organization became a district of the Federation. Among those who spoke on federation were Probate Judge Philip F. Bregstone, Mr. Nathan R. Kaplan, Mrs. Esther Natkin, Mr. Samuel Ginsburg, Mr. Steinberg, and Mr. Pearlstein. Those who opposed it were Messrs. Antenof, Levinson, Horwich, and Rabbi Schonefeld. The discussion was interrupted by the reading of an excellent paper by Prof. Kallen on "Double Patriotism."
The Kadimah Gate of Chicago was responsible for an excellent entertainment given in the Institute on Monday evening. There were musical and vocal selections and recitations, an address by Mr. Lipsky, and a mock initiation by members of the Kadimah Gate. The initiation ritual was written by Mr. Meites.
Mr. Nathan Kaplan, chairman on resolutions, closed the debate on Tuesday atternoon, after a number of interruptions, a running fire of questions addressed to Mr. Lipsky, points of order and of information, etc. Finally, the vote was taken, and showed that 36 voted yes and ı7 voted no, and quite a nımber of delegates nvı voting owing to lack of instructions. It appeared, however, that a substantial majority were strongly in favor of the resolution, and Mr. Shulman, the presiding officer, who had delivered a splendid speech in closing the final debate in favor of federation. derlared the resolution adonpted.
A number of resolutions bearing on Palestine work, on organization and propaganda were adopted on Wednesday. On Tuesday evening, a banquet was given, prepared by the ladies, headed by Mrs. Esther Natkin, at which several hundred diners sat down. Mr. Bernard Horwich was toastmaster. The speakers were, among others, Mr. Margolies, Mr. J. R. Schiff, Judge Harry Fisher, Prof. Kallen, Mr. Pedoff, Mr. Steinberg, Rabbi Rudzinsky. A presentation was made to Mr. Shulman, who also spoke, and to Mr. Pearlstein, the secretary, who expressed his thanks in a few remarks. A collection for the general fund was taken up, which netted about three hundred dollars.
The election was held on Wednesday. Although Mr. Shulman had decided to retire, he was urged to remain as president, with the assurance that he would be given generous support by the active workers, Mr. Shulman finally consented and was elected by acclamation. Other officers elected were: Secretary, Benjamin Pearlstein; treasurer, Judge Harry Fisher; chairman, shekel committee, N. D. Kaplan; chairman, National Fund, H. Steinberg; Palestine Workers’ committee, B. A. Antenof; deputies, Samuel Ginsberg, D. P. Pollock, A. Bernard, M. Kutshy, A. Levinson, B. Levenberg; orators, Rabbi S. Silber, Rabbi Budzinsky, G. K. Rosensweig, Dr. A. Levinson, S. A. Hoffman and Harris Horwich; Bezalel committee, H. L. Meites; vice-presidents, Bernard Horwich, Rabbi S. Schoenfeld, Frof. H. M. Kallen, Louis Gordon, and Samuel Gelb.
