treaty with Russia will be made; but American history ought to be a guarantee to you that no new treaty will be made with Russia except upon recognition of American principles of Governmental equality.
What you say about the futility of political activity in general, about the uselessness of leaning upon the broken reeds of modern Assyrias and Egypts may all be very true. But it smacks of the anti-Zionist Reformed Rabbi who pretends to be a prophet, and who would, as did a few, but by no means most, of our old prophets, condemn political activity of whatever nature.
Finally, everyone must endorse your plea for regeneration from within, but that does not prevent us from trying to better the outward conditions under which the Jewish people lives. The position of the Jewish people is so precarious that we must take advantage of every possible means of improving its lot. Let us not quibble over terminology.
J. L. MAGNES.
IV.
Strange it is whither controversy will lead us! Because I judge the abrogation of the Russian treaty by its actual and probable results, you find in me a suggestion of the anti-Zionist Reformed Rabbi. I might answer that because you judge it not by what it has effected or by what it will effect but by what we all hoped it would effect, you suggest to me very strongly the teaching of Paul that it is faith which is of importance, not works.
When you see "a moral victory for the Jews of the whole world," you are still under the sway of that thrill of enthusiasm which elated us all when the United States Government acted so decisively. When I fail to see this moral victory, it is because that thrill has passed, and I am faced with the probable futility of the spectacular political happening, so far as
regards the betterment of the position of the Jews of the whole world. The non-Zionist used to save his reputation after a Jewish defeat by claiming a moral victory. The Zionist is satisfied with nothing less than the real and the moral victory together.
I have read your second letter with care, but it hardly helps to settle our controversy. Your emphasizing the victory of the Jewish American citizen is entirely beyond the issue. The political importance and moral value of the American citizen on the Russian passport question has never been gainsaid by me. The notice of abrogation of the treaty was inspiring for Americans, including, of course, Americans of the Jewish religion. But reference to my original article will show that my contention throughout has beeu that “for the Jewish (not for the American or American-Jewish) people the effect of the abrogation will be negligibe.” Its after-effects on the Jewish people (without local qualification) will be nugatory.” “The spestacular abrogation of the treaty of ı832 is, in all human probability, Jewishly (not Americanly) of no importance.” I have been thinking imperially, Zionistically, not locally and parochially of Americans of the Jewish persuasion, or, if you prefer the classification, of Jews of American habitation. I have been writing of the effect of the treaty abrogation on the whole Jewish people. You have had in mind rather its effect on American citizens who happen to be Jews. I have written as a Zionist, you as an American.
Where we differ it is because of a difference of emphasis rather than because of a difference of principle. Thus, when you refer to the political teachings of the prophets you seem to think of a Deborah or a Shemaiah. I think rather of an Isaiah or a Jeremiah.
Let us be content to approach all such problems from our differing viewpoints so long as we may still work together for the Jewish cause.