The Maccabaean · Vol. XXIII, No. 1 · January 1913
21printed page
scan 21 of 32
THE MACCABÆAN
21

Jews, but of the Jews throughout the world. Do you not feel that you are a better Jew because you, living in America, had part in this open, heartening struggle to make the Jews of the United States citizens of the first class and on a paı with the rest of the citizens, instead of citizens of the second class, as they unfortunately are in every other country of ha wert?

Is it the fault of America that England and France have not had the manhood or the hardihood to deal with Russia as we dealt with Russia? You say that Russia well knows “that the free issuance of passports to Jews would mark the beginning of the end of the Pale of Settlement” Do you not think that those who carrıed on this passport agitation knew that also? And although America alone, without the co-operation of European countries, cannot bring the desired end about, do 'vou not see that the abrogation of the Russian treaty has been the severest blow ever struck at the Jewish Pale of Settlement in Russia, by having given notice to the Russian people that American prinsiples are not Russian principles, that American citizenship is higher than Russian citizenship, and that the Jews of America are on a par with the non-Jews of America?

But I would call your attention to the fact that the passport agitation was not carried on by the American people, Jew and non-Jew, for the primary purpose of abrogating the Jewish Pale of Settlement —however indirect a consequence of the passport agitation this may yet be—but it was carried on in order that the last distinction between Jewish citizens and non-Jewish citizens in this Republic might be brought to an end. It was the American Government that discriminated between Jew and non-Jew. It was the American Government that allowed a treaty to exist which was interpreted by the Russian Government in a Russian and un-American way. It was for this reason that the American Government, in order to be true to American principles of equality, was compelled to act in this American question

But though all the people of this land, Jew and non-Jew, acted in this question as American citizens, it was the Jews who performed the patriotic duty of calling this discrimination between Jew and non-Jew to the attention of the American public;

and as has always happened in American history—and let us hope always will happen—the American people responded in a voice true to American traditions.

Do you mean to say that this is no gain for the whole Jewish people? As a Zionist, do you not see that the fight of the American Jews was in spirit a Zionist fight, namely, that it was manly, unafraid and on behalf of the freedom of the Jews of this country? Is it so small a thing that one-fifth of the whole Jewish people should strike a blow for political equality? Consult some of the expressions of European Jews during and after the passport fight, and read their admiration, their joy, their hopes of American Jewry. How can we expect Zionism to become a reality except that the Jews of all the world Airst be freed, that they first learn the lesson of their individual freedom, in order to understand the meaning of the great Zionist ideal, that of the freedom of the whole Jewish neople as a people?

You seem to judge all of Jewish life by the standard of the existence «or the non-existence of the Jewish Pale of Settlement in Russia. I am afraid that you will have to wait a long time if you are to bid the Jews make no pohtical move unless it can give assurance beforehand of the abrogation of the Jewish Pale of Settlement ın Russia, But why so quick? As a student of history, you are lamentably impatient. It is not yet a year since Congress passed the resolution abrogating the treaty, and the year allowed by the treaty before its abrogation, has not yet come to an end. Who says that because England and France have not followed the American example this year, they will not follow it next year, or the year after, or the year after that? Do you know that Germany has taken more decisive steps than did England or France?

And do you not think that the enlightened opinion of England and France will some day shake itself clear of its Russian entanglements, and speak out for freedom, as it has so often done in the past?

Since when, finally, does a Zionist object to Jewish political activity? The Zionist theory has been attacked right along because we Zionists have been frank enough to say that the Jewish question needed to be looked at not alone from the religious or the educational or the sorial, but also