The Maccabaean · Vol. XXIII, No. 1 · January 1913
17printed page
scan 17 of 32
THE MACCABÆAN
17

undergone a similar process of broadening of their heads is very probable, and bracho-cephaly is by no means a convincing argument against their Semitic origin.

Finally, the hypothesis itself that the Jews have deviated from their primitive head form can be attacked at the root. How do we know that the pure Semitic type was dolicho-cephalic? We possess no skulls of the ancient Assyrians, Babylonians, Phoenicians, or Hebrews. The most ancıent Hebrew skulls measured by Lomboroso were bracho-cephalice True, the modern representatives of the Semites, the Arabs, the Assyrians and Abyssinians, are dolicho-cephalic, bı:t who can vouch for their purity? Abyssinians are only Semites by culture and negroes by blood. (34) Modern Syrians hardly retain much Semitic blood in view that Syria was the scene of such nation mixture from the time of Alexander. There remained, then, only the Arabs. Why should they be identified as the original Semitic type? Just as among the group of nations called the Aryans there are bracho-cephalic nations, as the Slavs, and dolicho-cephalic Teutons, and no one has ever dreamed to exclude the Slavs from the Aryan race, though it is certain that the original Aryans were only one small tribe (35) which imposed its culture on the rest of the peoples.. Who of the modern nations are its purest descendants is unknown. Why is it not the same case with the Semites, when the group of Semitic peoples appeared in history therı were bracho-cephalic Semites and dolicho- cephalic Semites; who were the original is not certain. None of these groups can claim superiority; antiquity of language is not always a fair sign of purity of race. The Lithuanian langrage is the most archaic of all Aryan tongues, and yet nu one claims them to be pure Aryans, arch- aism of Arabic is not a convineing proof and the bracho-cephalic Jew may claim pure Semitism as the dolicho-ephalic Arab.

Thus the historical belief of the Jews, handed down for generations, of race purity and race antiquity, of homogeneity of composition, of Semitic origin, is not a product of self-deceit, of vain-glory, but has its roots deep in the history of the

science of man. All attacks on it in the name of science have proven weak and far from convincing to any man except to the biased for whatever reason, who look upon things sub specie theoriae, and adjusts facts to theory, rather than the theory to facts.

CHAPTER II.

FHYSICAL AND PHYSIOLOGICAL TRAITS OF THE JEWS.

Tue physical and physiological traits of a nation are not only the r&ult of the racial blood but a product of the whole life of the race. In the long course of the history of its existence a nation acquires var- iows characteristics, which by consistent in- herence become heriditary and thus constitute secondary racial qualities; but by no means less important than the primary. With regard to the Jews, whose racial life has been so long and in many respects so extremely variable and unique, it might well be expected that their physiological traits, though accuired, should be many, distinct, and pronounced, and no actual line of demarcation can be drawn between primary and secondary characteristics. True, a number of the traits are a result of social conditions that have existed and still exist, and with the removal of the cause the effect disappears, but the majority ol traits are stable and can well be spoken of as ethnic traits.

Several of the physical characteristics, as head-form, color, complexion, have been mentioned before; some more have to be noticed. Of these, the stature of the Jews is important. The Jews are, on the whole, of short stature. Andree (36) even speaks of them as belonging to the shortest nations, but recent investigations have shown that this is not the case. The stature of the Jews differs only by two centimeters from the non-Jews (37); the average for Eastern European Jews is 162 centimeters, while for non-Jews, 164 centimeters. In some countries, as in England, the height of the Jews is equal to that of the Gentiles. In England, measurements

(36) Andree zur Volkskunde der Juden, p. 32.

37) Fishberg, The Jews, p. 44.