The Maccabaean · Vol. XXIII, No. 1 · January 1913
14printed page
scan 14 of 32
14
THE MACCABÆAN

but Zangwill has his hero declaim it with the fervor and assurance of an ancient prophet. He, of course, has in mind chiefly the Jews when he speaks of the disappearance of the old nationalities and the emergence of the new American type. And here many a stubborn, stiff-necked Jew will scorn the prophecy, and will insist that he has no desire to become anything different, He will refuse to yield to the disintegrating and reforming heat of the crucible. He will ask whether it is after all the will of God that he should do so,whether destiny's program is really as Mr. Zangwill has stretched it.

Prophecies are very impressive after they have come true. But before events have selected the particular prophecy that is to be crowned with the halo of truth, all prophecies have to be tested by our wishes and our sense of fitness. Mr. Zangwill's prophesy may sound ever so impressive, it may seem ever so "large," but if a considerable body of people obstinately refuse to be pleased with the prospect of assimilation, they will thereby frustrate the prophecy.

"The real American has not arrived." says Mr. Zangwill. "Washington, Lincoln, Emerson, Roosevelt, Wilson, these are not real Americans. They are only trial Americans. The real American will be the ultimate American; that is, he will be the product of a fusion of all the races that shall have settled in the land. But when will this complete fusion prophesied by Zangwill have been completed? In view of the large alien population in the country at present, the remoteness of the consummation seems very much like that of the climatic changes predicted by astronomers, a remoteness so great that we may safely lose interest in it. Mr. Zangwill's metaphor, the melting pot, shows at once what his conception of the assimilative process is, and wherein his error lies. If you heat and stir a number of elements in a melting pot you are likely to get a homogeneous mixture. A spoonful dipped over of one part of the pot will show the same qualities as one dipped out of another part. In other words, racial differences will disappear in America. There will be one type—the American.

History and present facts do not seem to point that way. The Maine Yankee and the Southerner of the Gulf States are more different to-day than their ancestors

a couple of hundred years ago. If the American continent is a crucible, it is a mighty big one. Railroads and telegraphs may diminish the barrier of distance, but they will never wipe it out. When the powerful streams of immigration that now run athwart the country shall have ceased and populations have settled permanently in their places, local differences will go on increasing rather than diminishing. Europe after centuries of fusing and mixing shows no uniformity of type, neither does any of its constituent countries. In little England alone we find such different types as Kipling has drawn in Mulvaney, Ortheris, and Learoyd.

The Jew, the Italian, the Irishman, and all the other nationalities in America will disappear, according to Mr. Zangwill. So the new mathematicians tell us that parallel lines are lines that, contrary to former teaching, do not forever remain apart, but meet somewhere "in infinity." Theoreticians find the discussion of the prolbem fascinating, but those who have to lay railroad tracks, build houses, bore tunnels and hang bridges feel safe in disregarding what may happen in infnity. In social life, it looks as if organizations like the Sons and Daughters of the Revolution, Descendants of the Mayflower, the Holland Society, the Hibernians, and so on, will continue for a good long time to arise. We should not forget the fact that there are people who are proud of their ancestors, who do not wish to forget them, but take pleasure in reminding us of their distinguished origins.

If the time comes when one man will say, "My great-grandfather was a Jew and my mother was an Italian," and another will say, "My great-grandfather was a negro and my great-grandmother an Irish woman," and a third will proudly declare, "I don't know who my father or mother was and I don't care," there will still be another who will arise and proclaim, "I am a thoroughbred, my remote ancestor landed at Plymouth and he married a woman who came over on the next boat. I am the only genuine American."

With the disappearance of races there will also disappear, according to our author, differences of religion. Can anyone really foresee the disappearance of the Catholic religion in America? Or does anyone feel confident in predicting, in spite of all its