ganizations and insurance companies." In other words, the so-called East Side is taking care of itself to a very large extent. Considering their numbers, we may expect that in the next decade responsibility for the improvement of Jewish conditions will be transferred to them.
Immigration Restriction.
UNLESS the unexpected happens, the Burnett bill, which provides for a literacy test for aliens applying for admission into this country, will soon become a law. At the present time, the bill has passed the House, and will go to the conference committee, where, in all probability, it will meet with the approval of the members of both Houses. There is a possibility, though very slight, that the conference may undertake to amend the bill, but there can be no further discussion of the subject in either the House of Representatives or the Senate, according to the rules. What influence may be brought to bear upon the conference committee, or, in the last resort, upon President Taft, to prevent almost certain passage of the bill, is not at all apparent, and it seems that the American Jewish Committee, which has appeared in the matter at Washington, is not sanguine of success. At least, the Committee is prepared to accept the inevitable, and, it may be, will not force the issue to meet certain defeat, preferring to stand by the arguments it has advanced against restriction of immigration at previous sessions of Congress. The passage of the Burnett bill, therefore, may be said to mark a new era in American government. Congress thus decides to abandon the policy that has made the United States rich in numbers, in wealth and in opportunities, for the sake of a provincial and utterly untenable policy of excluding peoples representing alien cultures and races. The Burnett bill is the first step in the direction of exclusion of aliens on grounds other than merit. The United States no longer will welcome the labor that has helped to build it up. It will no longer take pride in the fact that here all cultures mingle and form a new amalgam that excels in quality any of the human products of Europe. It is no longer a free haven of refuge for the oppressed of all nations. Let those who have been preaching of America as the Land of Promise adjust themselves to
the new conditions. We wonder what new theory they may invent to meet them.
Dr. Schulman's Chanukah Message.
DR. SAMUEL SCHULMAN is one of the able men of this country. His opposition to Zionism, expressed at times with great force, has been consistent and maintained without partisan animus or unfair personalities. That we disagree with him we need not say. We do not believe that a Jewish religion without a national or religious centre is possible. We think that Reform Judaism without Zionism is nothing more or less than assimilation. In a recent sermon printed in The American Hebrew, he speaks of "the emphasis of religion as against nationality" as one of the elements of strength in Reform Judaism. He says that religion among the Jews "always transcended nationality and land, and that political nationality was a temporary instrument to be superseded in time by the thought of a Congregation of Israel witnessing to the everlasting truth for which the Jew stood." The fact is that in its opposition to nationality, Reform Judaism abandoned the strongest quality of the Jewish people. For once the Jew abandoned the thought of land and nationality, even as an ideal or a pious wish, he lost the material platform on which "the Congregation of Israel witnessing" could stand. The Jew in Goluth may be likened to a man walking in shifting sands. He cannot proclaim the truths he stands for because he is bound to think too much of his feet. He is afraid to stand and be a witness, for the sands bear him away, and he is not to-morrow where he was yesterday. Dr. Schulman, however, is coming around a bit to a more acceptable idea, to which he has given expression not once, but many times. We quote from the same sermon the following as an indication of the progress his thought has made: "It should be our business to recognize with sympathy and with reverence every form of Jewish life that has vitality and that is helping some Jew to lead a better life and to remain loyal to the Jewish spirit. For nothing Jewish should be alien to our hearts. Every belief, every movement, every symbol, every sentiment that is helping some Jew to retain his allegiance to Israel, should be met by us with reverence and with sympathy."
