Jewish support for Mr. Sulzer was that Mr. Sulzer deserved Jewish consideration for what he had done for the abrogation of the Russian treaty. This was a wholly uncalled for attempt to aid in the defeat of the Jewish candidate for the governorship of the largest state in the Union, and was generally resented in Jewish circles. Still, it is possible that Mr. Marshall may overcome these defects in his attitude toward Jewish problems when he bears the responsibility for the future course of the American Jewish Committee.
The Schechita's in America.
One of the most troublesome problems in American Jewish communal life is the proper control of the Schechitah. In many cities it is the source of endless and bitter controversy, some rabbis of the old school holding office merely as the heads of factions that battle for the control of the perquisites of the Schechitah. This is due, probably solely, to the haphazard development of communal authority here. The rabbis may have been compelled to take the matter in their own hands in the absence of any organized control by the householders; in other words, by the community itself. Here and there, however, order is being created out of the chaos of the past thirty years. In one city, like Rochester, N. Y., the Schechitah is managed decently and with dignity by the householders, with whom the rabbis were forced to co-operate. It is now reported that in the large and influential community in Philadelphia steps have been taken to administer the Schechitah by the Kehillah recently organized with Dr. Cyrus Adler as its president. It is proposed in that city to adopt the successful English method which has been tested by a century’s experience. A Board of Schechitah will be formed, to be composed of one representative for each congregation, one representative of the community at large and the president and treasurer of the Kehillah. The Kehillah will keep all accounts and act as the administrative office of the Board. The rabbis who have been the source of a great deal of disorder, are to be treated as the servants of the community. This is the first step in the direction of a proper and democratic organization of the Jews of Philadelphia, as it will be, if it is taken, in other cities.
In New York, where the Kehillah has been in existence for three years, no serious attempt has been made to organize the Kehillah on the basis on control by the congregations. Here, all negotiations have been conducted with the dealers in meat and with the rabbis. That the rabbis are not the key to the situation is apparent from the lack of success that has attended the New York Kehillah’s efforts to organize the Schechitah.
The Emancipation of the Immigrant.
THE immigrants who came to the United States since 1880 are gradually assuming the responsibility for communal progress. During the past five years or so, they have come to the front to a remarkable extent, establishing their own hospitals, charities, educational institutes, etc. In fact, in a number of cities, the immigrants from Russia and Galicia control the situation. Even in New York, the depot for a large majority of the immigrants, our brethren who only a few years ago were regarded as requiring the solicitous care of the older settlers, have taken over, to a large extent, the management of their own affairs. There are now two or three East Side hospitals maintained by Russian and Galician Jews. There are several excellent Talmud Torahs; there are kindergartens, Hebrew classes, mutual benefit societies, fraternal orders, and the finest example of a free loan association owes its success to the energy and devotion of Jews of the later migration. It is often impossible now to distinguish the older settlers even in those institutions they consider their own. In a number of them, the newer emigration is merged with the older. This new development is noted in the annual report of the New York United Hebrew Charities. The United Hebrew Charities reported that it received 689 applications for relief less than the previous year. It accounts for the decrease in this manner :“ This continuing decrease in the number of families demanding and requiring assistance is a growing indication that the Jewish immigrant from all countries is taking full advantage of the opportunities afforded here for a livelihood and more than this, is exercising thrift and prudence in providing against emergencies of illness, unemployment and accident, through the various mutual help agencies such as fraternal or-