The Maccabaean · Vol. XXII, No. 6 · December 1912
180printed page
scan 4 of 34
Facsimile · scan 4 of 34
Scan of p. 180
Text · transcribed from the scan

siding at an annual meeting of an Ito branch, spoke, however, with confidence of Angola as a possibility, although the final report of the Angola commission had not been received. Speaking of the proposal to make Salonika a free city under Jewish auspices, he said he was not so keen about Salonika as an Itoland, considering, among other things, its already large Jewish population. He seems to prefer a territory where there are no Jews, in order that there may be room for others. Palestine, by a curious optical illusion, does not come within the range of the Ito’s vision.

The Chief Rabbi of England.

It is now the general opinion in England that Dr. Bernard Drachman has the lead in the competition for.the Chief Rabbinate. The Jewish Chronicle, which judiciously trims its sails to the successful communal winds, has abandoned, it seems, the candidacy of Dr. J. H. Hertz, and now (November 26) suggests that all candidates withdraw in Dr. Drachman’s favor. Jt seems to us that the controversy will gradually reduce the importance of the office to zero As the difficulty increases, the value of the office decreases. Should a selection finally be made, it will be found to be an empty honor. It is now apparent that the sovereignty of the Synagogue requires the training of an heir-apparent in the lifetime of the incumbent. Leaving the office vacant even for a day after the death of Dr. Adler violates the principle involved. The office of Chief Rabbi, if it is to have any value, should, like the office of the Pope, continue forever without interruption. Once the office is vacant, even for the election of an incumbent, the office itself is endangered. Should Dr. Drachman be selected, he will probably find that all respect for the Chief Rabbinate will have disappeared.

The American Jewish Committee.

THE annual meeting of the American Jewish Committee does not arouse the interest it deserves owing to the policy of excluding the press from its deliberations. The result is that comment on the meeting must be deferred until its secretary issues an oflicial statement of what has transpired. The subject of immigration, it is said,

was uppermost in the consideration of the Committee. The status of the treaty with Russia was also discussed. The likelihood of a restriction bill being introduced in Congress the coming spring is not apparent, and what the Democratic party will do, in view of the liberal utterances of President-elect Wilson on immigration, need not cause Jewish concern. Mr. Wilson’s views are expressed in a letter written to Dr. Cyrus Adler. He said: “I think that this country can afford to use and ought to give opportunity to every man and woman of sound morals and sound mind and sound body, who comes in good faith to spend his or her energies in our life, and I should certainly be inclined, so far as I am concerned, to scrutinize very jealously any restrictions that would limit that principle in practice.” The American Jewish Committee elected Louis Marshall to succeed Judge Mayer Sulzberger as its president. Judge Sulzberger is one of the few men who enjoy the full confidence of every element of the Jewish population. He is a man with broad, statesmanlike views. He is genial and generous in his thinking. He is free from partisan bias, and interested with keen zest in all things that make up the complex of Jewish life. Such a man, with his ripeness of knowledge and experience, is a fit leader for a representative body of Jews, in spite of the fact that its representative character was not made by the direct mandate of the people. At least in Judge Sulzberger the Committee had arrived at a selection of its leader, which met with universal approval.

Mr. Marshall, who succeeds him, is well-known for his zealous defense of Jewish interests. In the agitation for the abrogation of the Russian treaty, he took a leading part. He has sterling fighting qualities. He represents in a dogmatic manner the opposition to the nationalist view of Jewish life. Only a few weeks ago, speaking at Pleasantville, N. Y., he reiterated with strong emphasis the idea, now absolescent in this country, that the Jews are members of a religious denomination, and not of a race or a nation. In the recent election, while an ardent supporter of President Taft, he went out of his way to advise Jewish voters to support William Sulzer for Governor in preference to Oscar S. Straus. The reason he gave for asking