Hebrews, whoever they were, and are to be considered racially pure and not intermixed through the long ages of tbe diaspora. It is also to his credit that Luschan and his school are by no means prejudiced or biased. It is only on the basis of their researches that they have formulated this hypothesis.. But there are more radical and more biased men who are inclined to deny entirely any purity of race to the Jews. This choir—in itself a mixture—by no means racially pure, consists of men of various professions, anthropologists, linguists, Semitic scholars, anti-Semites, as well as Judophiles, among them such two extremes as Renan and Leroy-Beaulieu. But all their hypotheses, founded or not founded, and scientific guesses are collected in Dr. Fishberg’s book, who availed himself of every opportunity. According to Dr. Fishberg, the modern Jews do not present a homogeneous type. Their head form is not uniform, varying from eighty to sighty- six for the brocho-cephalic.e. There are also dolicho-cephalic Jews—the validity of this argument will appear later. The cranial type of the Jews in: countries where they have lived for centuries coincides with the cranial types around them. (6) Adding yet the large amount of blondes, fair-eyed and haired, we must come to the conclusion—in his opinion—that the Jews have no claim to ethnic unity, and that the only cause for this variety of types of Jews is intermarriage. The modern Jews are not the descendants of the ancient Hebrews, but the result of crossing between mediaeval Jews and the neighboring peoples.. The Jew in Russia has less kinship with his co-religionists in Morocco than with the Slavs among whom he lives, so with the Jew in Germany. (7) To substantiate his theory he repeats all the historic evidences cited by Renan and others to disprove the racial purity of the Jews. The Jews were, from ever, an assimilating people—all kinds of proselytizings are quoted, the conversion of the Cozars,; Arabs, and Phalashas; the embracing of Judaism on a large scale during the Graeco-Roman period—mentioned by Josephus and Philo— the slave trade, the recent intermarriages, all possible and probable causes are cited in proof of the theory of the racial im-
(6) Fishberg Ibid p. 511.(7) Loc. Cit. 517.
purity of the Jews. These are in brief the arguments against the ethnic unity of the Jews. How much truth they contain and how much bias, especially in the historical evidence, remains for us to see.
The arguments advanced by many and especially by Fishberg against the purity of the Jewish type, are partly of an anthropological character and partly historical, the last, as it will appear further, have very little historical truth, but even the strongest side of the argument, namely, the anthropological, can easily be interpreted in a different light when not beholden from the narrow point of view of an assimilator. The homogeneity of the Jewish type, its unity and marked distinctness of expression, in spite of the small differences in head form and color, is accepted by most of the anthropologists. “We all know the Jewish type,” says Andree (8), “We discern him immediately even among thousands, by the expression of his face, his whole habitus, behavior and manner.” Even the anti-Semites in the Middle Ages knew it. : Wagensiel writes, “Ac Judaeus ex habitu cultuque corporis nullo negotio a Christiano digndscatur.” (9) Even the negroes in Surinam when they see a Jew and an Englishman approaching, will not say, “Here are two whites coming,” but “Here comes a white and a Jew.” (16) Fishberg argues for heterogeneity of the Jews on account of their differences in the measure of their heals, but how little importance can be attached to this can be seen from the fact that Mr. Fishberg himself, in his article on craniometry in the Jewish Encyclopedia, comes to the conclusion that the measurements of the Jews are homogeneous on the whole. In fact, says Zolschan, “No perfect unity of crania is there to be found in any race” (11) The differences of the Jewish crania even according to Fishberg are slight. They vary in Europe, where the bulk of the Jews are found between 81.05-83. (72) The small amount of the extremely bracho-cephalic Caucasian Jews do not alter the
(8) Andree: zur Volkskunde der Juden. p. 37. (9) Loc Cit.* (10) Loc Cit. (11) Zolschan: Die Rassen Problem, p. 8. (12) Fishberg, p. 52.