THE ETHNIC CHARACTER OF THE JEWS
The following essay was awarded the Henrietta Szold prize for 1912, in the Prize Essay competition instituted by the Federation of American Zionists in honor of Henrietta Szold.
CHAPTER I.
THE ETHNIC COMPOSITION OF THE JEWS.
THE most essential proof necessary för a people to establish its claim to be called an Ethnos, so as to be able to speak of its character as ethnic, is the purity of its race, the homogeneity of its social composition. Ethnie society is such a society, wherein the chief bond of its members is blood relation. The term Ethnos is quite distinct from that of nation, the latter does not imply unity of descent, The French, the Spanish, the Italian peoples can by no means claim homogeneity of composition and yet no one will ever attempt to rob thenı of their nationality. -
Nationality in the widest sense is identical with the notion of national conscious- ess. “A nation,” says Leroy-Beaulieu, “is in the first place a product of history; what creates and preserves it is a community of interests, of traditions, and feelings.” In the course of history, heterogenous elements living in the neighborhood of each other may fuse together so as to acquire what sociologists call a common consciousness and thus become a nation Nationality, therefore, is a created thing, a product of a long process of amalgamation in which process territory constitutes a chief creative factor. An Ethnic nation. however, connotes something more than the simple term. It is a nation that in addition to its created national consciousness, possesses also purity of blood—and the ethnic character of such a people is not only a product of its history but also of its racial element. There are very few ethnic nations in Europe, and among those the Jews can claim the foremost place—yet, however, even their claim is not without dispute. Tt is the irony of fate, that the nation which was considered for thousands of years the typical Semite, whose enemies
pride themselves in the name anti-Semites, and from whose Scriptures the name Semite was borrowed, should be finally refused a place among this family of nations; yet such is the case.
In recent anthropological literature, the question, “Are the Jews Semites ” is an open one. Many eminent anthropologists have decided the question in the negative, and what is more deplorable that they have also cast a doubt on the purity of a certain race hardly affects its purity, for whatever the origin of a certain people may be, whether it is to be classed as belonging to the Semitic family or not, it still can be considered ethnically pure. Its stock having been preserved through centuries ‘in its purity without intermingling with other peoples, thus constitutes an Ethnos. But as the people in cuestion are the Jews, it is to be expected that in discussing their origin strict adhesion to scientific methods should be disregarded, and bias should play ari important role As usual, among those who want to rob from the Jews the purity of race, are also found a number of men who are themselves of Jewish descent, and with the customary characteristics of this class of Jews, they are the foremost among the assailers, and not regarding scientific truth, they seize every doubtful fact to prove their theory. Of such a character is a book recently published by an American Jew* wherein the author endeavors to rob from the Jews not only the name race, but is very reluctant to grant them even the name nation, or people. The Jews, according to him, are not only not Semites, but the most impure of all nations, a mere conglomeration of all kinds of peoples and races. In view of this recent tendency, it is necessary
*The Jews: A Study of Race and Environment, by M. Fishberg.