The Maccabaean · Vol. XXII, No. 6 · December 1912
187printed page
scan 11 of 34

seemed to have waned. The new leaders were abler, more influential, more resourceful, than the old. Without a change in the alignment of forces in Jewish life, however, the old organizations could not be displaced. But with the rise of the demand for direct representation in Jewish affairs, the gentlemen of the Jewish Committee saw their opportunity. They made themselves part of the movement. They seemed to be willing to take advantage of it in order to place themselves at the head of Jewish interests.

But with the organization of the Committee by the co-optation of its members by an inner committee, the democratic sentiment was not satisfied. Co-opting members was not sufficient. It was felt that some form of direct election must be devised.

MANDATES FROM KEHILLAHS

The Kehillah was a local stream that had its source in the general feeling that every individual had the right to a voice in Jewish life When the New York Kehillah was formed as a reply to the Bingham charges, the American Jewish Committee saw an opportunity to attach itself to an organization that was democratic in form and represented, in theory, the largest aggregation of Jews in this country. Finding it to be inadvisable to get its credentials in any other way direct from the people, it decided to get them from local Kehillahs, Thus it was hoped that in time the Committee would for all purposes be the actual instead of theoretical representative of American Jewry.

But, while swimming with the current of democratic progress, a majority of the members of the American Jewish Committee had not freed themselves from their traditional prejudices against the new ideals of Jewish life. They took cognizance of the New York Kehillah, but were averse, it seems, to have it go along without control. They therefore entered the first Kehillah convention, participated in its deliberations and were potent in swaying the Convention to their point of view. They were men of large influence and of forceful personality. They maneuvred an alliance with the Kehillah, which was embodied in its constitution. The American Jewish Committee reserved jurisdiction

over national affairs, and seemed to grant the privilege of taking care of local affairs to the new Kehillah. The executive members of the Kehillah became members of the American Jewish Committee. An executive committee was provided for, one-fifth of whose number went out of office every year, thus making a change of administration impossible in less than three years. As local leaders in Jewish affairs, the representatives of the American Jewish Committee were elected to office in the Kehillah, and being in both organizations, they felt secure against insurgent movements. They thus acquired practical dominance over the subordinate body.

This control is generally regarded as detrimental to the interests of a free Kehillah. It is the dead hand of obsolete policy strangling the growth of the ideal of Jewish self-government in our local Jewish life.

A USELESS APPENDIX

Further evidence of a willingness to grant the form but not the content of self-government is evident in the alleged existence of the so-called Advisory Council.

This pseudo-democratic appendix, given a name but no function, which has been the laughing-stock of the community owing to its ludicrous endeavors to find out why it was born, was intended as a weak concession to democracy. The Council seemed to have been given powers, but in fact had none. It could not influence the work of the executive committee. It had no voice in the framing of policy. It was turned loose in the hurly-burly of Jewish life and told there was much good work to be done.

There is always good work to be done. The seventy unfortunates of the Council knew that. But the Council as such had no function in the Kehillah government. It was not advisory or directive. Its advice or direction could be legally ignored and it has been treated with contempt. The Council therefore spent its time in futile and exasperating discussions of its place in the economy of life and unable to arrive at a rational conclusion, every man of the seventy, with few exceptions, has been a bearer of unfavorable tidings of the Kehillah to his friends.