The Maccabaean · Vol. XXII, No. 6 · December 1912
186printed page
scan 10 of 34
186
THE MACCABÆAN

country that would involve elementary propositions. Nor is it necessary for Jews who have emigrated to this country. They have come here filled with aspirations for free, democratic conditions of life. Furthermore, may they be presumed to have learned something from our leaders, who have been preaching American ideals for the last thirty years?

The pupils seem to have profited by these lessons, but their teachers have forgotten them. The preachers of democracy in American life are fearful of the results of democracy in Jewish life. It is the sons of persecution who are behind the demand that the New York Jewish community be organized on a democratic basis. It is because the Kehillah has neglected to listen to their demands, crudely put, often indirectly and offensively urged, that it is now facing a crisis.

It is axiomatic that there can be no Kehillah unless it is democratic. That is implied in the name, and especially an American Kehillah which has no power to coerce support, must keep its finger constantly on the communal pulse. Its form of organization must allow free play for public opinion. To ignore or to affect to ignore it is fatal. Its success, therefore, is to be measured not so much by what it does as by how it does it.

That is to say, the Kehillah may accomplish a great deal of concrete good, but unless it has the direct backing of a broad, democratic constituency, it becomes not an efficient Kehillah, but an efficient bureau of education, or an efficient Waad-ha-Rabbonim, or efficient in the specific work it is doing. As a Kehillah, its unequivocal aim should be not to establish institutions, or to do specific acts of benevolence, but to create and become the government of the local affairs of the Jewish community. What that government shall do must be left to its citizens.

Who will say, measured by this standard, which is the traditional and only possible standard in a country where representative government is in vogue, that the New York Kehillah is such an organization? Or that a majority of its leaders have earnestly and consistently desired or aimed to create such a Kehillah?

Yet, when the Kehillah was organized, that was the ideal of those who aided Dr.

Magnes in his efforts. How was this ideal frustrated? How was it transformed into the anomalous thing which it has become?

The first step in the confusion of the Kehillah's ideal and its decline as the official representative of the community, which it aspired to be, was taken when it entered into what seems to have become an indissoluble alliance with the American Jewish Committee.

ALLIANCE WITH THE AMERICAN JEWISH COMMITTEE.

That committee was born out of a keen desire of a number of influential Jews of the East to form a national organization to act for American Jews. But while appreciating the value of a representative body, in theory, they were, it seems, averse to having the larger affairs of American Jews reviewable by the people at large, in large committees or public conventions. They had no confidence in such methods. They wanted to have the people behind them, but, at the same time, seemed not to have the courage or the assurance or the willingness to organize them.

This attitude was consistent with their previous training in Jewish affairs. It agreed with the prevailing Jewish ideal not to assert special Jewish interests. For many years American Jewry had been represented in its national affairs by agents with carte blanche mandates from organizations like the Union of American Hebrew Congregations, or the Independent Order B’nai B’rith, or by men who spoke in their own names, or as alleged representatives of various organizations. But with the growth of the Jewish population, the conflict of political ideas and personal ambitions, the development of Zionism and its subordinate currents of opinion, a growing sentiment required that men speaking for the Jewish people be their accredited agents and that their credentials have something written in them by their constituents.

. This sentiment was used by the men res- .ponsible for the American Jewish Committee, to take the control of Jewish affairs from the Union of American Hebrew Congregations, the Independent Order B’nai B’rith and from other responsible and irresponsible “leaders of the people.”

The powers of the organizations named