The Maccabaean · Vol. XXII, No. 4 · October 1912
118printed page
scan 22 of 32
118
THE MACCABÆAN

two editors, Michal Cohen, severed his relationship with it. As long as the paper was under joint editorship it enjoyed the friendship and support of the Haham Bashi Abraham Ashkenazi and of the Rabbi of the Magribs, Haham David ben Simeon. But as soon as Frumkin assumed the full charge of it, he could not, on account of his independent nature, manage to keep at peace with the Rabbis. In the third year of its existence the paper incurred the wrath of the Rabbis for the insertion of two articles by Simeon Trachtman, namely, Me Heayyam and Mesilath Haosher, which were taken as heretical. Since then there existed a constant friction between the editor and the Rabbis who wanted the paper under their censorship. As this demand was not granted, the Rabbis finally succeeded, through the intervention of the Turkish Government, in having the paper closed. But it soon reappeared with renewed vigor and increased support, which always results from a fight. After this complete breach with the Rabbis in 1877, Frumkin took revenge by directing all his efforts to promote progress and Haskala and to criticise the ways and systems of the Rabbis and the trustees of the Kolelim.

This was not the end of the fight between the conservative and progressive factions of Jerusalem. There soon came to the front another cause for the display of bitter feelings. This was the attempt at founding a library. Jerusalem already had schools and newspapers and only a library was now missing for the spread of culture. In 1877 Moses Luncz suggested that a library should be erected in the name of Montefiore in honor of his ninetieth birthday. As soon as Montefiore learned of this project he sent the necessary funds for it and asked that the library should also bear the name of his wife. The library was thus called Beth Moshe We Yehudith; but its existence was very brief. Though every evening a portion of the Talmud was studied together by the readers, the Rabbis feared that the library should in the long run become a centre for heresy and heretical books, and also be an incentive for forsaking the Yeshiboth. They thus demanded from Montefiore to withdraw his name from the library, and as soon as he did it, they put the library under excommunication and deprived of Halukah all those attending it.

The library became so deserted that it had to be dissolved, and the books were kept in a corner of the printing house of the Habasseleth.

basscleth. The outcome of all this antagonism was, as we have seen, in favor of progress. That spiritual war between those who stood for the past and those devoted to the ideals of the future, resulted in a new intellectual era, the era of Haskala. This era was also marked by a great advance in Talmudic studies. Through the Talmud Torah, the Seminary Etz Haim and six other Yeshiboth that had been formed for the mature and old scholars, the systematic study of the Talmud was developed. The literary productions of this period are of the greatest value. The work Tifereth Yerushalim, by Jehuda Lew Kutna, has become an essential supplement to all the books of the Mishnayoth. His book, Zaith Ra'anan, is a classical work in the literature of the Talmud. The commentary of the late Mordecai Hirschensohn on the book Shethile Zethim has become in Yemen the text book on Halacha. The book Imre Binah of Auerbach is also of great value. The books of Joseph Schwarz and of Jacob Saphir are even to these days a great help for all those who make scientific investigations in Palestine. Michel Pines' book Emek Beracha, which aims to prove from Halachic sources that the Rabbis do not have the right of excommunication, was of no mean service. The articles of the Habaszeleth furnished to Smolenskin material for his Haschachar. Finally, Moses Luncz's book Nethiboth Zion We Jerushalaim, must also be mentioned among the valuable contributions of the period. Luncz is the editor of the yearly scientific reviews Jerus'alaim and Luach Hashanah; those reviews are indispensable to the Jewish and Christian scholars for all that concerns Palestine. There were also several other newspapers that appeared at that period, but they were of a short duration, such as the Ariel, by Michal Cohen, the Sha'are Zion, by Haim Press, and Yehuda We-Yerush- alaim, by Moses Salomon.

The seventh period of our classification, the nationalistic or Zionist period, starts with the year 1882. No real line of demarcation can be traced between the preceding period and this new one, and no doubt the contemporaries were not con-