ist) or who is only a Chowewe Zionist is no Jew, then you would have been quite right to call me Chauvinistic and fanatic. But I have not said so. I only make a distinction between national Jews and no Jews. If I were not a national Jew I would be neither fish nor fowl. For in regard to my manners, or to my ‘weltanschanung,' I am at least of all that which is generally called a Jew. For that reason I made the comparison with the Frankists, whom I do not recognize as Jews at all, whilst I am inclined to consider many converted Jews as national Jews (e.g. Chwolson). Why then did the orthodox Rabbis think my remarks went home to them? Evidently these gentlemen take the most one-sided sense of the word Zionist, m the sense of the word ‘Herzliänismus,’ and hence this striking misunderstanding. But it is not my fault. I express clearly and distinctly what I understand by the word “Zionist.” For me all Chowewe-Zion, Herzliäner, national Jews are synonymous. The difference between these groups is only in the means by which they hope to achieve the aim. You should have understood that, as you agree with my program speech. In the sections 2, 3, 4, I do not appear as an accuser, but as a defender of Zionism against its enemies open and secret. I say unconditionally that when there are orthodox Rabbis who show enmity to Zionism, they commit a sin, and I justify this statement. Either there are such, and I am quite right; or there are not such, and nobody can say that it goes home to him, those least of all who are connected with the idea of Zion. Now I know exactly that our main opponents consist of many orthodox Rabbis, orthodox Jews, Chassidim, and the so-called Assimilants. I hear that day after day. As an illustration of the intolerance you might take the recently published case where a Rabbi was censured by a colleague because he dared to take part in the Basle Congress. About Easter-time I received from one of my most trusted colleagues the news that just before the foundation of the Bank, a coup against us was planned by a group of orthodox Rabbis. This it was that excited me most, for I was afraid that such an affair could do great damage to our work. It goes without saying, that I generally have perfect respect for those Rabbis who fulfil their duties with dignity;
I acknowledge and am thankful that our Rabbis appreciated and preserved Judaism till the beginning of this century; but I do not doubt that most of our Rabbis of to-day are not suited for their profession. That which protected us before the degeneration in the Ghetto does not keep us any more, and the process of detrition proceeds with great speed. Most of our present Rabbis do not do anything for the preservation of the Jewish spirit; they have no knowledge, and are fanatical, and in fact do not care for anything else than their petty personality. I appreciate the more men, like this Rabbi, whom my letter so hurt, and I am very sorry that he had misınderstnn me ;
"Hypocrisy irritates me always. and nothing can make me more furious than when hypocrites, who in life commit the lowest actions, call themselves the 'real Jews,' and do not want to have anything to do with the civilized Jews.. But I am equally disgusted by the offensive expressions of some Zionists, who 'push the baby out of the bath,' and who hurt without any reason the religious feeling of the orthodox Jews.
M. MANDELSTAMM.Kiew, March 26, 1899.
III.
"Thank you heartily for sending me the valuable essays about the Blood Accusation. But you would be mistaken if you believed that I ever should make use of the material you sent to me to defend my co-religionists in this question. If the misfortune happens to anybody to fall into a robber's or a murderer's den, no logic, no appeal to human or divine righteousness avails to avert the murderer's hands; one looks for a favorable underguarded moment to run away. If it is possible, well and good; if not, death.
“Since I began thinking and searching into the psychology of our people, I have become deeply convinced that you cannot hope to do anything with these antediluvian troglodytes. One only lowers oneself and does not further anything by it. He who suffers has .not to bother about the particular gibe directed against him, For that reason I have preached for fifty years, though with a voice crying in the desert, that we must deliver as many Jews as possible from this Russian hell; those who