The Maccabaean · Vol. XXII, No. 3 · September 1912
70printed page
scan 4 of 32
70
THE MACCABAEAN

frankly played the Democratic party against the Republican in order to settle an issue of Jewish value, it is not now so difficult to throw the weight of its influence against the present Republican administration. Four years ago if the Secretary of the Committee had publicly become active in the national campaign, his resignation would have come simultaneously with his entrance into the political field. This year, Dr. Herbert Friedenwald announces the fact far and wide, personally and officially, that he has been given a leave of absence of three months to engage in the campaign in the interests of Governor Wilson. The Committee transfers Dr. Friedenwald from his office in the Charities Building to the offices of the Democratic National Committee. Mr. Schiff, known to feel aggrieved at the treatment accorded Jewish interests by President Taft, has issued a letter favoring the election of Governor Wilson, and Mr. Schiff is one of the most influential members of the American Jewish Committee. It is a pity, however, that the Committee does not take official action, pointing to the broken pledges of the Taft administration, and advising Jews to vote, other things being equal, for the Democratic candidate. This would be politics that involves risk, but it would strengthen Jewish influence in the American government. THE MACCABAEAN has no objection to the Committee becoming entangled in political activity, but it does object to its refusal to stand squarely on a platform or policy which its own acts, official or otherwise, clearly show it has decided to follow.

More Politics.

THE MACCABAEAN takes no part in political events transpiring in the United States. It is a bystander, observing the tendencies that affect American Jewish life and drawing conclusions from the facts. In the making of the facts it takes no hand. Zionists are bound to regard the political life of the lands of exile as separate and apart from their Zionist activities. Should an incident in American governmental life affect Jews as a whole, in their rights as Jews, we may with propriety exercise our functions as citizens and aid those Jewish organizations designed to protect Jewish rights. The denial of any political right of Jews as a class by government is a

Zionist concern. This was the principle which inspired the Zionist organization last year to aid in the agitation for the abrogation of the treaty with Russia. And we see how it may become a Zionist duty in the United States to participate in politics should the immigration question take the turn which it seems about to take. Should, for example, the Jews be singled out for attack by the restrictionists, it would become the duty of all Jews to unite in the defence of the rights of our people. Aside from this, however, it may not be amiss— it is clearly within the limits of our duty— to say that in our opinion the parties that are now entered in the presidential contest may be judged from a Zionist point of view, other things being equal, and a Jewish preference, always with other things being equal, may be expressed. The protective theory, as a force in American political and economic life, is upheld by the Republican party and by the party organized by Mr. Roosevelt. The protective theory is not only unsound from an economic point of view, but from a political point of view leads inevitably to the restriction of immigration. The manufacturers of favored articles are now protected against foreign competition. As soon as the working classes are aroused to their rights, they, too, will ask that they be protected against the incoming of their competitors. The theory that a few may be favored at the expense of the many cannot be maintained for long. Inevitably, if the steel magnate is protected, the man who works in his mills will demand the same privilege. Thus, the protective tariff is the mother of the trusts, and it will, if the protectionists are consistent, also be the mother of the labor trust, which will demand the exclusion of competing workmen. And an idea works itself out consistently even if those who profess it refuse to go the limit. Protection means exclusion. Now, foreign manufacturers are excluded; in time foreign workmen will be prevented from entering this country. The question will not be, is this alien knocking at the door capable of supporting himself, is he strong, able, bringing skill and energy? But the affirmative reply to this question will suffice to exclude, just as at present a confession that an alien has no trade, is not strong or energetic, may lead to his exclusion. It seems, then, to be the duty of persons interested in the