and otherwise turning the Jews in Turkey into full-blooded Turks, according to the best-approved models of -Jewish assimilation in Western Europe. Everything might have been possible then, and it is perhaps dificult why it should b& more absurd for Jews in Turkey to pray in Turkish or to study the Talmud in that language than it is for the neighboring Hungarian Jews to identify themselves completely in their intellectual life with that kindred tongue. As it is, the Turks had never induced Jews in their midst to identify Jewish with Turkish culture, and the attempts that were now made in that direction were such that roıld not sıucceed.
Apart from the old-world instruction 'in Hebrew religious literature, the only educational agency among the Turkish Jews was üntil recently the Alliance Israelite. To the spirit and tendencies of that great organization reference has repeatediy been made in the Jewish press, but now comes the sensational news that the Alliance intends to withdraw from its activities in Palestine, or even from the whole Ottoman Empire. It is added that this step will be followed: by a concentration of the educational work of the Alliance in Morocco. It would be a fateful step if the Alliance carried this rumor into effect, 1t is also rather difhcult to believe it, as the Alliance, which is French to the backbone, would evacuate an outpost of French culture which it has held and developed at such great cost. It is, however, most likely that the Alliance will restrict itself to its present engagements in Turkey generally, and will withdraw so far as possible from its commitments in Palestine. The halo of the Alliance in Turkey has become somewhat dimmed when the Jews, as well as the Turkish authorities, discovered that the education in the Alliance schools in Turkey was neither distinctively Jewish nor Turkish, and aimed more in giving a smattering of French culture If this was the case in Turkey generally, where, up till recently, the Turks paid little attention to the education of the subject races, it has for a long time past been become painfully evident in Palestine, which has naturally attracted the attention of the Jews from all over the world. In Palestine the whole system of the Alliance seems to have been built upon the perverse idea that those passing through the schools of the Alliance were to be equipped for emigration.
Instead of adopting its protéges for local conditions, and strengthening the local element by the infusion of young, vigorous blood, the Alliance brought up the alumni of its schools as strangers in their own homes, and with the sole ambition and qualifications to make a home somewhere else.
If there be any doubt as to the practical workings of the Alliance system: of education, we may convince ourselves by the figures quoted in its last annual report. Take the case of the agricultural school, Mikveh Israel, near Jaffa. Fourteen pupils of the fourth (highest) class left the school last year, and what has become of them? Three of them were sent to the Argentine; one went there to join a brother, a former pupil of the school (with these four the director sent an old pupil who had been in a good position in Egypt) ; two left for New York, where they are working. under Mr. Henry Lustgarten, another old pupil of Mikveh Israel; the others obtained good positions in or near Palestinee Thus we find on the one hand that even lucrative positions are to be had in Palestine itself, for which the growing colonizing activities in that country provide ample scope, but what justification is there, under such circumstances, for sending graduates of the school direct from tlıe classrooms of Mikveh Israel to the Argentine or to New York? We should have thought that the Argentine colonies were for the benefit of people from lands of persecution, and that it was quite a waste of money and energy to train young Jews as agriculturists in Mikveh Israel and then to send them to the New York Babel. Of course, the authorities of the Alliance might not be able ° to keep the old pupils of Mikveh Israel either in the country or at agricultural pursuits, but it is quite another matter to act as an emigration agency, which encourages not only present but past pupils to leave their homes and families and to spread all over the world. There is not a shadow of excuse for it. The central authorities of the Alliance might learn something from the report of the director of their agriceultural school at Djedeida, Tunis, who recalls the principle that it ıs advisable to place Tunisians on Tunisian farms and Algerians in Algeria, for it is, as he says, by such ocular examples that the Jews in Tunis and Algeria will be convinced that agriculture is worth while,