The Maccabaean · Vol. XXII, No. 3 · September 1912
78printed page
scan 12 of 32

chance to emancipate themselves and take their share of the glory?

The next essay, "The Spiritual Revival," is an able exposition of Zionism and outlines the conception involved in the phrase "cultural work." Admitting that in Palestine only, the land of our ancestors, can Israel accomplish its spiritual ideal, there is much work to be done instantly if the return to Palestine is ever to be accomplished. This work consists of the diffusion of the Hebrew spirit and in providing a home of refuge for the national spirit.

"But what is this you are striving for? What is that individuality you seek to maintain?" the world asks. Even Nietzsche admits in his "Genealogy of Morals," that the Jews have a genius for morality and in that respect are the superiors of all other nations. We do not know how this trait was developed; but we find that in the very earliest times the Jewish people became conscious of this; and this consciousness found its expression in accordance with the spirit of that age in the religious dogma that God had chosen Israel. This consciousness of its moral election has been preserved by the Jewish people through its history and has been its solace in all its sufferings. The Jews have never tried except in exceptional circumstances, to increase their numbers by conversion; not as their enemies aver, out of jealousy, nor yet, as their apologists plead in excuse, out of tolerance, but simply because it is a characteristic of the superior type "that will not consent to lower the value of its duties by making them the duties of all men."

In the essay on "Moses" Achad Ha'am gives us the Moses as he has been created by Israel, in its own image, the Moses who has been our leader not only for forty years in the wilderness of Sinai, but for thousands of years through all the wildernesses in which we have wandered since

the Exodus, who stands like a gigantic pillar of light on the threshold of our history. This is the most inspiring essay in the book. Here the author reveals himself to us as the grand interpreter of the spiritual character of Judaism. In an earlier generation those who were liberally inclined sought to minimise the differences between Jew and non-Jew by saying that there really was no difference, that what appeared to be a difference was really external and of no importance. How they could ignore the vast difference that exists between Jew and non-Jew is hard to tell. But the feeling was there, and many Jews and non-Jews accepted it as profound truth. However, with the growth and development of the Jewish national spirit the Jews have grown to realize the importance of their singular individuality and the importance of maintaining it. This realization has breathed a new spirit into the character of Hebrew learning; and it is in Achad Ha'am that the Jewish claim for a distinct culture of their own has found ample justification. Not with an abundance of reasons has he accomplished this; but by a true manifestation of the substance of this culture he has demonstrated its value in its own weight. In the midst of the depravity of modern Anglo-Jewish literature this book is truly a godsend. With the noteworthy exception of Mr. Segal's "Book of Pain Struggle," whose singular vigor and beauty must make a lasting impression on us, and possibly Dr. Schechter's Essays, no book portrays so vividly our highest national ideas or expresses so thoroughly our importance as a nation.

In conclusion I will remark that the book has an able translator. In rendering these famous essays into English, Mr. Leon Simon has made them accessible to a much wider circle of readers and they will surely bear fruit.