a man of extreme character, whose dominion is absolute justice. The priest is the man of the hour. The prophet occupying himself with eternal principles, can be extreme. But the priest, dealing with men, must be practical and compromise. Moses was an ideal prophet. Aaron was an ideal priest. Moses went up to God, while Aaron compromised with the people by giving them a god of gold. The struggle between priest and prophet is another factor in the development of Judaism.
Asceticism has so frequently been associated with religion that many people are liable to associate it with a movement in which religion must be a great factor. Judaism takes no choice between the extremes of materialism, which means a complete abandonment to the pleasures of the flesh, and asceticism, which is a sacrifice of the flesh for the spirit. Both these extreme views, holds Achad Ha'am in the next essay, "Flesh and Spirit," having no root or basis in the heart of the nation, will disappear and give place to the only view that really has its source in Judaism, which is neither the sovereignty of the flesh over the spirit, nor the annihilation of the flesh for the spirit's sake, but the uplifting of the flesh by the spirit.
"Many Inventions" is directed against those very lofty and wise ones who abandoning earth for some remote region in the clouds look down with contempt upon the "poor earth-worms" below. To this extreme of human and Jewish thought Nature says: "Be thou not righteous overmuch, nor make thyself overwise."
In the next essay, "Slavery in Freedom," the author directs his literary searchlight upon the spiritual condition of the self-styled "emancipated" French Jewry. These narrow emancipated souls of France!—but are they much worse than our own little dry goods dealers, who, having attained that height from which they can command a few dollars credit lose all interest in the national hope? These "emancipated" Jews of France champion their religion against rival religions—because it is permitted. But when they have to disclose their national connection with Jews of other lands, then we discover the depth of their social slavery—a spiritual yoke which throttles them and reduces them to a condition of undisguised degradation.
Should the Jew bow down in awe and
reverence beneath the contumely heaped heaped upon him by practically the entire world? That is the subject under discussion in the next essay, "Some Consolation." Achad Ha'am declares that it is a moral sin for a nation to bow before the decree of an uncultured, uncivilized multitude. And pointing to the blood accusation he says: "But, you ask, is it possible for everybody to be wrong and the Jew right? Yes, it is possible; the blood accusation proves it is possible. Here, you see, the Jews are right and perfectly innocent. A Jew and blood complete contradiction? And yet . . . ."
The next essay is "Ancestor Worship." Here the author discusses the relations between modern Judaism and antiquity. There is really no genuine need for a detailed code of religious observance; but because we are slaves to the past some of us still carry out every detail of the Shal- hun Aruk. But we may hope for the time when we feel the tragedy that lurks beneath even the most barbaric relic of the past without being compelled to regard our tradition, in all its details, as a body of laws and ordinances superior to time and place.
The next essay, "The Transvaluation of Values," I have already discussed. The following, entitled "A New Saviour," is no less than a severe and well-deserved castigation administered to M. Reinach ("The New Saviour") who, after refusing to give a hearing to a deputation of Jewish agricultural laborers, published in a French Jewish paper an article on "The Internal Emancipation of Judaism," in which he calls upon the "enlightened" Jews of the West to unite in aid of their brethren in the East, so as to free them from that inner slavery in which they are unk at present, and which is responsible for all their troubles. This "inner slavery" is the observance of the Sabbath and the dietary laws! We are indeed very fortunate in having among us one who is so profound a thinker and who besides his vast mentality has also the virtue of being generous and is willing to give these "poor slaves" of the East the "light" they need! But as he boasts so mildly of how he emancipated himself and the glory of it, why cannot our new "saviour" be kind enough and give those "poor" Eastern Jews a