The Maccabaean · Vol. XXII, No. 3 · September 1912
76printed page
scan 10 of 32

sophy in something like the following manner: “From the time since man first felt the enchantments of Nature, etc.” forgetting that man’s experiences on earth did not begin with love of Nature, but on the contrary, with a fear and dread of her mysterious forces to which he was mercilessiy exposed, and that he could not appreciate the enchantments of Nature until he had reached a high stage of development. Primitive man roaming across the plains with nothing to shelter his body from the menaces of Nature and the wild beasts of the forest conceived the idea that behind each one of these persecutions there was some hideous monster to whom he must bend for mercy if he would be spared. This was his nature-god and he had one for each different manifestation of natural phenomena, But primitive man’s struggle was not solely against Nature and ‘the wild beasts of the forest. He had to struggle with his brother for the maintenance of life, and sometimes his brother proved to be a more destructive adversary than even the wild beasts of the forest. So each family had its household god, whose only excuse for living was to protect his family from all others. But when the families gave way to nations these household gods lost their importance and either disappeared completely or became pet household spirits. Then came the national gods. Hence, when the abstract idea of the Unity of God spread among the Israelites in early days it could not possibly be more than an anticipation. In vain the prophets labored to breathe the spyrit of life into this belief. It was so far removed from the contemporary current of ideas and feelings that it could not possibly root itself firmly in the heart, or find a spiritual thread by which to link itself to real life until long afterward.

The national hope as embodied in the idea of the return to Palestine affords in a much later age an instance of a survival come to life again. Just as the prophets despaired of the time when Israel would realize fully the idea of the Unity of God, so this national hope, too, losing its support, soon ceased to exert any spiritual influence and became a doddering creature—a survival. But the spirit of society moves in a circle, and now the revolution of life's wheel has carried the spirit of our

people from point to point on the circle, until now it begins to approach once more the healthy condition of the long age.

ET EEE ET AUT Me “Past and Present” explains two other forces in the development of Judaism. The hope of a future was essential to the life of the earlier Jewish state. Presently we are building upon the past, and on it we depend for spiritual nourishment. There is a radical difference between the individual ego and the national. An individual has his period of “The Song of Songs.” middle age when he makes his “Proverbs,” and old age when he says “vanity of vanities.” The individual whose existence is endangered is certainly at liberty to seek escape by any means and to find a refuge in any place. But the national Ego, the eternal ego of the Jewish people, has its career well marked out by its essential character; and that character has its promise in the past and its fulfillment in the future

Humanity gazes at the stars, full of longing for these bright spheres, unconscious of the fact that the very light by which they are made visible is constituted by struggl.e We envy Socrate’s hearing the “heavenly harmony,” ignorant of the fact that it is only through the selfish wrangling of the heavenly bodies that it is constituted. And so when a new idea which we do not understand presents itself we lose ourselves in admiration, turn back on the old ideas for which we have suffered so long and intensely, and blindly demand that they be swept off the universe. In “Two Masters” we find that the old and the new ideas are two other creative forces, the struggle of which propells the rotary progress of society.

The argument that assimilation is merely another form of imitation is met in the next essay, “Imitation and Assimilation,” and ably disposed of. Imitation is indeed one of the most faithful factors in the progress of a nation. But when a nation has reached the point of assimilation it is no longer imitating; it has reached that stage of history where it has lost all confidence in itself, where it has exhausted all its own resources, and can no longer depend on itself for life Assimilation, far from being imitation, is national suicide.

The next essay, "Priest and Prophet," is both scholarly and inspiring. The Prophet is an emancipator, a Utopia maker,