The Maccabaean · Vol. XXII, No. 1 · July 1912
6printed page
scan 8 of 40

Mr. Abel withdrew his amendment. Mr. Kahanowitz stated that any plan to buy land in Palestine should be favored. Dr. Magnes believed that the presentation of this resolution had served its purpose, for it had brought the attention of the delegates to the fact that there is such a thing as the "Hoachooza," and it behooves them to study the matter for their own sake and for the sake of Zionism in the places where they live. He was doubtful as to whether the Convention should place the stamp of approval on this plan or any other kind of a plan. Each delegate ought to consider the matter and find out the merits of the various plans for land purchase and colonization. The Hoachooza plan appealed to him personally because he happened to know what has actually transpired in Palestine on the basis of the Hoachooza plan of St. Louis. On the Lake of Galilee a small group of St. Louis Jews are doing well. Most of them have purchased a large tract of land which is actually being cultivated on this very day that we are here considering the matter. The land is very fertile and hundreds of almond and olive trees have been planted on it. Buildings have been erected and affairs are in charge of an administrator. Animals are pulling American plows. From reports sent out monthly from Palestine to St. Louis, it appears that the plan inaugurated by the American pioneers living in St. Louis is working out well. It is the duty of every Zionist who wishes to accomplish some good for Palestine, who wishes to buy land in Palestine for himself and family, friends or for someone else, to give close attention to this particular plan. If the Zionists assembled at the Convention would take hold of this plan in their respective cities, there could be gathered a very large sum of money for land purchases and for effective Jewish colonization in Palestine. This offers some kind of a form through which American Zionists can express their concrete Zionism. It was a matter of indifference to him whether this particular resolution passed, but it ought to be brought home to every Zionist that there is in America a group of men who have accomplished some benefit in behalf of Palestine and Jewish colonization there.

Dr. Heller was of the opinion that if we simply said that this Convention commends

the Hoachooza movement for the purchase and cultivation of land in Palestine we would not then recommend any special plan. He proposed an amendment to the effect that the word "idea" be substituted for the word "plan." As thus amended the resolution was unanimously carried.

An Emma Lazarus Garden City

Mr. de Haas presented to the Convention the following resolution:

"That this Convention raise, within the shortest possible time, a fund not less than five thousand dollars for the establishment of a garden city in Palestine in memory of Emma Lazarus."

Speaking on this resolution, Dr. Heller dwelt upon that stage of Jewish American history when Emma Lazarus came over to the Jewish fold, and he paid a fine tribute to her memory. Upon the immigration of Russian Jews to America consequent upon the proscriptive May laws of 1881, Emma Lazarus rose to the defence of her people with the warmest enthusiasm for everything pertaining to Judaism. Dr. Heller added that, having been in America at that time, the name is very dear to him and he was most heartily in favor of perpetuating her memory to tell the world that this woman was with us heart and soul. Had she lived to-day she would undoubtedly have been one of our leaders. He felt, however, that it would be a mistake to build a garden city of that sort in her memory, as the large sum thus expended could be put to more needful and vital purposes in furthering Jewish colonization.

Mr. S. Abel explained that the garden city plan involved the erection of suitable houses for the workmen of the district in which the city will be established, and met Dr. Heller's objection with the statement that the work would be done by Jewish laborers, and that the garden city plan would therefore be a direct benefit to them.

Mr. de Haas shared Dr. Heller's admiration for Emma Lazarus. He did not, however, believe in personal Zionism and the outlay of large sums of money for the erection of tablets, etc., in memory of distinguished people of the Jewish race. We should not measure our ideal by money and turn our movement into financial calculations. He raised no objection to the