The Maccabaean · Vol. XXII, No. 1 · July 1912
4printed page
scan 6 of 40

SUNDAY AFTERNOON SESSION

Telegrams of greeting were read from Congregation Yavne of Boston, I. J. Maltin, and the Young Austro-Hungarian Society of New York. A telegram from the Order Knights of Zion of Chicago was to the effect that the organization stands for peace.

The report of the Credentials Committee created a spirited debate on the question of the seating of the delegates representing the various Texas societies. Mr. Solomon, the chairman, submitted the following report:

TO THE FEDERATION OF AMERICAN ZIONISTS:

Your Credentials Committee reports as follows:

First: The list of names annexed hereto we find are legally elected delegates from the societies named, and should be seated as such at this Convention.

Second: The Tifereth Zion Society from Pittsburg, Pa., has been seated by us, notwithstanding the fact that their shekel taxes were paid to the Zionist Council ot Pittsburg, Ba, instead .of.to the Federation ofick "We ‚desire, .kawever,.to express our disapproval of such a manner of payment, and recommänd: thät irt tie future payments should, ofly Be *r&tognized for shekel taxes that are*paid.to Yhe: lederation office.

Third: "Mr. L: ?A-:Freed has been recognized as a delegate by us from one society, as shown in the annexed list. He also appears as a delegate upon the credentials of the following-named societies: Houston Zion Society, Houston, Tex.; B’nei Zion of Galveston, Tex.; Sons and Daughters of Zion, Galveston, Tex.; Workers of Zion, Austin, Tex. He claims the right to substitute for himself, as a delegate, other persons selected by him. He also claims the right to substitute for other societies whose cases have not yet been presented to us, similar names selected by him. While the societies are in good standing, they do not comply with the law that each society must elect its own delegates, and we, therefore, leave the decision of this matter to the Convention.

Fourth: Mr. L. H. Rubin presents credentials from the Zion Association of New York City. This Association has applied for a charter and paid the fees for same, and also all other required dues, but

the charter has not yet been issued, for the reason that the payments were made too late.

We cannot seat Mr. Rubin as a delegate on that account, and ask the Convention to determine this matter.

THE COMMITTEE: S. D. SOLOMON, M. BRODSKY, MORRIS KURZ, B. A. LICHTER.

Mr. Avner moved that the report of the Credentials Committee be amended by permitting Mr. Freed of Texas to substitute proxies for all societies which he represents except for the one he chooses to represent.

Rabbi Drob raised the point of order that no individual has the right to choose delegates.

Mr. Freed thought that it was within the power of the Convention to seat delegates. He stated that the societies which‘ elected him as their represenative are in good standing. In short, they elected him as the State representativee He found that it was impracticable for him to represent all the societies who selected him, and the submission of the particular names to the committee was not done for political reasons but for the purpose of giving these societies equal representation.

Mr. Brodsky was not in favor of allowing Mr. Freed to choose these proxies.

The Chairman ruled that inasmuch as there is nothing in the Constitution of the Federation against this method of procedure, he could not rule the motion out of order.

Rabbi Margolies stated that inasmuch as the Texas organizations only have one man to represent them, we ought to give them the number of delegates they are entitled to, and allow Mr. Freed to fill out the credentials.

The contested delegates in cuestion, named by Mr.Freed, were Max Kolinsky, Joseph Morgenstern and George Laufman. Mr. Freed had not named all the delegates Texas was entitled to and was somewhat in doubt as to the exact number, and inasmuch as the debate seemed to have reached a stage where it threatened, to