The Maccabaean · Vol. XXII, No. 1 · July 1912
16printed page
scan 18 of 40
Facsimile · scan 18 of 40
Scan of p. 16
Text · transcribed from the scan

Mr. Avner, who was chosen on the side opposing the resolution, stated that it will take years to perfect a satisfactory plan. We all agree that there should be a district organization where it is necessary, but we have no guarantee that the district idea is going to solve our problem. This reorganization plan may weaken the main organization! It is not organization that gives us strength, but the workers in the organization. If we adopt this platform of prorata representation we will have an Executive Committee that will be scattered all over the country. A scattered executive is absolutely useless and a fixed residence executive is far more preferable. While the present organization may not be perfect, yet 15 years' experience has demonstrated that a fixed residence executive is better. We are not yet ready for grand lodge organization. Modify your resolution by preserving the executive as you have it, and create such sub-districts as, in the opinion of the societies, may be necessary.

Mr. de Haas, for the affirmative side, made a strong plea in favor of the resolution and stated that if it passed the convention, the claim of the Knights of Zion to be an independent organization would cease and there would be unity between it and the Federation. With a district organization we can create a more positive Zionism and a much stronger group of Zionists.

Mr. Max. Shulman, Grandmaster of the Order Knights of Zion, was asked if the resolution was agreeable to his organization, and he replied in the affirmative.

The resolution was framed in two parts, and inasmuch as the second part, which went into the details of the plan, was somewhat involved, it was decided to refer it to the Resolutions Committee to have same redrafted and presented to the Convention during the afternoon session. The first part of the resolution was voted upon and adopted. It is as follows:

"Whereas it has been found expedient to change the present form of organization for the purpose of unifying the methods of propaganda and creating a standard of harmonious co-operation, and whereas there are now large Jewish communities that have not as yet been reached, due to the

lack of co-operation, and whereas the prime factor in the success of any movement is a defined plan of organization,

"Therefore, be it resolved that a number of districts be created from time to time in accordance with conditions that arise and in accordance with geographical locations, giving groups of societies the right to organize with local power within its territories, provided such groups sell at least 2,000 shekolim."

Report of the Nomination Committee

Mr. Avner, Chairman of the Nominations Committee, submitted the report of that committee, and the Convention voted on the report in the afternoon session. In connection with the oce of the Chairman of the Executive Committee, Mr. Avner stated that Mr. Lipsky had served notice to the effect that for personal reasons it is impossible for him to continue the sacrifices he has thus far made for the movemem, and desires to retire for a year. The Committee feels that it would be advisable to ask Mr. Lipsky to make some sacrifice, but not an absolute sacrifice. If the pledges made by the delegates for the propaganda fund, as well as those made at the banquet will be kept, the finances of the Federation will be in such shape that there will be no deficit for the coming year and the Federation will be in a position to provide some nominal salary for one of the workers on the Executive Committee. We feel that we can safely recommend that the Convention elect Mr. Lipsky as Chairman of the Executive Committee and provide for him a nominal sum of $1,000 to make it possible for him to throw off some of the work he is doing to make a livelihood. It will be a sufficient sacrifice if he will give us his promise to accept the position on that basis.

Mr. Avner asked leave to set aside the report of the Nominations Committee to place the following resolution before the Convention:

"Resolved that the Executive Committee is hereby authorized to provide a sum of $1,000 for the coming year to be placed at the disposal of the Chairman of the Executive Committee for personal expenses."