The Maccabaean · Vol. XXII, No. 1 · July 1912
15printed page
scan 17 of 40
THE MACCABÆAN
15

Mr. de Haas laid before the Convention the resolution relating to the reorganization scheme, providing that instead of having the societies directly responsible to the Federation, the country should be divided into districts, on geographical lines; that these should elect representatives to constitute the supreme executive of the Federation. This resolution, if adopted, will make possible the reconciliation of the Order Knights of Zion with the Federation.

This resolution consumed nearly all the morning and part of the afternoon session. Apparently, the delegates were unprepared to vote on it.

Mr. S. Abel did not favor the approval of the resolution until the Executive Committee had had an opportunity to work out the plan. Experience has clearly shown the necessity of having members of the supreme Executive Committee living in one place where they could all meet together. Sufficient reasons do not exist for making such a radical change. District organization is not new and the organization is not strong enough to be divided into districts. There would be active and inactive districts and this would have a demoralizing effect.

Mr. Brodsky favored the appointment of a committee to look into the plan.

Rabbi Ashinsky did not see why a radical change in the organization such as that set forth should be brought before us at the eleventh hour. We should not begin new plans for organization when we have not completed our present one. Organization takes time and changes are risky and might possibly lead to demoralization, There is no denying the fact that there ought to be freedom and harmony with the Knights of Zion. We should avoid hasty action, however, and refer the matter to the societies for their deliberation.

Mme. Pevzner favored the district organization idea. It will create competition and more work will be accomplished. Her experience in some of the large cities demonstrated to her satisfaction that more work was accomplished when the activities were scattered into districts. If the plan does not prove successful, the next Convention can alter it.

Rabbi Hershman differed with Rabbi Ashinsky's views and stated that the plan sounded plausible to him, as it will tend to eliminate our differences with the

Knights of Zion. Two large organizations like the Federation and the Knights of Zion being at odds tends to cripple Zionist work in this country. Seven districts will mean seven federations on a small scale, but acting in harmony. We must not, however, devote out time with matters of organization to the detriment of Zionist work.

Mr. Fishman did not favor the district idea and stated that we are groping in the dark and seeking methods that are not feasible.

Mr. Rubin was of the opinion that we should adhere to the old organization.

Mr. Freed suggested that Mr. Schulman, Grandmaster of the Knights of Zion, who was a guest of the Convention, be permitted to express his views on the question.

A Mr. Schulman, when called upon, stated that at no time did the Order Knights of Zion bear ill will towards the Federation, or carry on a competitive sort of propaganda. The ultimate goal of the Order is to organize Zionist societies where no organized Zionism exists.

Mr. Lipsky explained at some length the issue existing between the Federation and the Order Knights of Zion.

Mr. Fishman’s motion to appoint a committee of 7.from the Convention to confer with a committee from the Order Knights of Zion and bring the entire question up before the next Convention was ruled out of order.

Rabbi Margolis was of the opinion that the Convention was afraid to assume responsibility. Let us work out this plan and make the districts responsible. Placing responsibility on the various federations will serve to make them realize the necessity of performing their proper functions. We must have organization. There is no such thing as over organization. We have no organization now.

Rabbi Ebin spoke in favor of the resolution.

The debate seemed endless, as many more delegates voiced their desire to speak on the question. In order to limit the debate, it was decided to have the remaining delegates who had not spoken on the question, and who seemed equally divided on it, chose a spokesman on each side, after which the matter would be put to a vote: