The Maccabaean · Vol. XXII, No. 1 · July 1912
11printed page
scan 13 of 40
Facsimile · scan 13 of 40
Scan of p. 11
Text · transcribed from the scan

back for effective propaganda is due to the small support rendered by the individual societies:

"Therefore, be it resolved that the Federation dues of each member of an affiliated society be one dollar ($1.00) per year, payable in semi-annual installments of 50 cents each."

Mr. Schechter moved that this resolution be adopted. This was duly seconded.

Mr. Samuel Friedlander, the author of the resolution, explained same in detail and maintained that this Convention should place the Federation on a firm foundation so that we may not have to continually apply for charity.

Mr. Fishman contended that if we raised the dues, the affiliated societies, in order to meet the increase without embarrassment to them, will report a smaller membership than they actually have. He could not see how the salvation of the Federation hinged on this resolution. Zionism is a movement of the masses, and we ought to recruit more members into the fold instead of over-taxing the affiliated Zionists. He believed that the matter should be referred to a referendum vote of the organizations.

Mr. Lipsky expressed the view that it would be inadvisable to imjpose a tax on all the societies by simply asking the vote of the delegates, who have, no authority to act on the question, and believed it proper to refer the matter to the individual societies.

Mr. Frankel stated that small donations here and there will not place the Federation on a firm footing. If we are the right kind of Zionists and desire a strong Federation, we must meet our financial obligations.

Mr. Brodsky observed that we ought to have a larger membership, and that the question of increased taxation should be referred to the societies for decision.

Rabbi Heller moved, and it was carried, that discussion of this question be limited to 15 minutes and that not more than 2 minutes be allotted to each speaker to present his argument for or against the resolution.

A delegate expressed the view that the societies who sent their representative here ought to be bound by the decision of the Convention and that the delegates, he believed, were fully capable of voting prop-

erly on the question. The Federation must have the means with which to carry on its work.

Rabbi Hershman favored taxing each Zionist $2 or $3 a year, part of the money to go to the support of the Federation and the balance to the various Zionist institutions.

Mr. A. Goldberg favored the $1.00 tax, and stated that the Federation had no traveling propagandist due to lack of funds. If the Federation could send out a propagandist and add thereby more members to the fold, the tax would become much cheaper. We ought to furnish the Federation with sufficient funds to carry on its work and then give it a year's time to demonstrate to us if such plan works out successfully.

Dr. Magnes averred that with a large number of Zionists we will have a considerable income, but with a small number we need a Jarger tax. The problem before us now is how to meet the present emergency, how to tide the Executive Committee over another year and enable it to do its important work. We ought to take advantage of our being here together and ask each delegate from each city just in what way he thinks Zionist work in his particular town can be improved with the aid of the Executive and just how the Executive ‘can imProve Zionist work in his particular town. Let each delegate stand up and say just what is needed in his particular town or center. .

Mr. Freed maintained that we have come here to determine the correct solution ot our propaganda problem and the method of strengthening our organization. Means must be furnished. Our organization is entirely too cheap at the present time to permit of much progress. We in this country should have the largest Federation of any country in the world, and we are simply neglecting our opportunity. We must take il upon ourselves to pay this increased per cafpita tax. We should have three times as many Zionist societies that we now have. We should not only raise the tax but see to it that the Federation receives same.

Dr. Friedenwald suggested that further consideration of this resolution be deferred until the afternoon session, in order to give the delegates an opportunity to discuss the question amongst themselves. This was agreed to and the Convention adjourned.