Jewish communities on our ancestral soil as well as experiments along the line of social reform.
II. A Co-operative Association of Jewish Farmers.
In a former article, entitled: “A Social Commonwealth in Zion,” appearing in the October, 1910, issue of the MaccaBAEAN J] have implied that the theories of Franz Oppenheimer do not go the full length of a comprehensive program of social reform. They present no adecuate plan for a_ social commonwealth. No doubt, much good will be derived from well regulated colonies for co-operative farming, but we cannot expect a_thorough-going solution of our grave economic problems by advocating co-operation in agriculture. Farming is only a part of our industrial system—a very important part, it is true; but we must face, likewise, the problem of unemployment, poverty and wage-slavery which are intimately connected with commerce and manufacture.
It is my aim to demonstrate that we can construct a “Social Commonwealth” upon the basis of co-operative farm colonies, so that the latter will form the foundation of a true Commonwealth. Utilizing the theories of Franz Oppenheimer as well as the practices of the thrifty farmers of Denmark, we can build in the Holy Land a large community of Jewish farmers bound together in a co-operative society, for extensive buying and selling, that shall operate as a mutual protective association. There are, altogether, about five thousand Jewish colonists in Rishon-le-Zion, Rechobeth, Zichron Jacob, Mikvah Israel, Pesach Tikvah and the smaller colonies stretching from the immediate vicinity of Jaffa to the neighborhood of Haifa. Let us, for the moment, ignore the petty disputes in the colonies themselves and the external obstacles which may prove discouraging. We may then look into the future and conceive a large co-operative association of Jewish farmers with lands stretching from Jaffa to Haifa along the coast of the Mediterranean Sea and inland for several miles. Let us assume that this.co-operative association will have strong financial resources, so that it shall have succeeded in converting the whole district between
Jaffa and Haifa, with a hinterland of several miles, into one huge Jewish colony with many more thousand inhabitants than the Jewish pioneers of to-day. We would have a Jewish yeomary to serve as the backbone of the Hebrew community. The co-operative association would encourage individual initiative while it would co-ordinate all activity for the larger material success for all of the members.
So far, the theory of a co-operative association of the Jewish farmers may lead us to the beautiful picture of a series of model farms cultivated by a large community of thrifty and prosperous Jews. The portrait seems well drawn, but it is incomplete; the landscape may attract the eye, but it cannot satisfy the heart and the brain.
There are several perplexing questions which such a plan could not answer. What will be the status of the farm laborer, of the man who tills the soil for wages and has insufficient capital to become a landowner? If the community should offer him nothing more than the low wages of a farm-hand, we might establish a prosperous community of landowners resting upon the foundation stone of wage-slavery. We must establish an oligarchy whose members would live by the labor of numerous serfs, even as Sparta maintained its existence by the unrewarded toil of the helots.
Furthermore, if the community is to restrict itself to agricultural development, it could hardly expect to support a large population, with cities of culture as the centres of its civilization. It might become tributary, economically, to the industrial centres of England, Germany and America. It could not hope to attract to itself that large and influential portion of Jewry that has achieved success in industry or won fame in the domain of arts and science. Such men are residents of the larger cities of the world. The modern city undoubtedly presents many evils, but it furnishes the opportunity, likewise, for the development of the highest products of our age. It has often been remarked that the Jews is attracted to the large cities—the seats of industry and culture, of commerce and learning. Naturally, the Jew, who is in the forefront of economics, and who strives with might and main for achieve-
