The Maccabaean · Vol. XXI, No. 12 · June 1912
338printed page
scan 20 of 38
338
THE MACCABÆAN

While Franz Oppenheimer cannot be regarded as the originator of the idea of co-operative farm colonies, yet to him belongs the credit of demonstrating the economic value and the feasibility of co-operation in agriculture. The farmers of Denmark, for example, have succeeded in establishing strong co-operative associations for the purpose of collective buying and selling. Thus, the farmers unite in huge organizations (resembling somewhat the "Granges" in our country) to which they forward all the cheese, butter, eggs, etc., (over and above the portion which they retain for home use). The association then acts as a selling agency, disposing of the products in the best markets and awarding to the farmer the sum due him in proportion to the amount of products of each (after deducting the actual expenses incurred by the association). This association, because of its large activities, is enabled to secure the services of experts, to engage the most competent sales-agents and to save to its members the profits accruing from transportation on a large scale. The same association acts, likewise, as a buying agency in purchasing costly machinery, including agricultural implements with the latest improvements, which the individual farmer would not be able to secure because of the high cost. Such machinery may then be utilized by the various members of the association on the payment of a small rental to defray the expenses actually incurred. In short, such co-operative associations of farmers retain the principle of competition among their members for the purpose of encouraging each to increase their products (and thus obtain a larger share of the profits), while adopting the principle of co-operation as against the outside world so as to eliminate cut-throat competition and insure stability and progress.

Franz Oppenheimer, perhaps more clearly than anyone else, has perceived the immense value of such organizations, and has presented the logical basis which justify their cxistence as economic units. Unlike co-operative manufacturing establishments, these “Granges” do not restrict individual initiative; and they differ from communistic schemes because the latter sanction the dangerous principle of equal reward for unequal effort and unequal productivity. A co-operative association of

farmers places no hindrance upon individual ingenuity and individual perseverance It merely consolidates and co-ordinates these forces into a successful co-operative scheme. While such efforts might be viewed as “‘Socialistic’ from the point of view of marking a distinct step in co-operation as distinguished from haphazard competition, these associations, are, nevertheless, compatible with competitive industry and tend directly to preserve competition within the limits so defined. Franz Oppenheimer, therefore, is justified in concluding that co-operative farming colonies are utterly unlike co-operative manufacturing establishments or co-operative stores. The former encourage individual enterprise, while the latter rely for success almost exclusively upon co-operative efforts. To put the matter concretely: each farmer member of a co-operative association must know that his reward will depend almost exclusively upon his individual industry (and his good fortune), while the worker in a co-operative factory must soon come to the conclusion that his welfare depends only in a very small degree on his own efforts and to a very large degree upon the industry of his fellow-workingmen. For example, if there be one hundred factory hands, the industry and honest labor of one will count ror little if the remaining ninety-nine be shiftless and unfaithful. In order to establish a: highly successful manufacturing community based upon co-operation, we must first develop the unselfish spirit of co-operation to such a degree that each individual will work with the same intelligence and energy for his neighbors and comrades as for his own family. This may imply such a transformation in individual character as may require decades for its completion. But we can successfully institute co-operative colonies for farmers in our own day, since we can utilize not only the unselfish motives of the idealist but also the selfish promptings for individual success that seem to form the basis of business enterprise at the present time.

These fundamental considerations have popularized the schemes of Franz Oppenheimer for co-operative farming settlements in Palestine. Such farm colonies could readily be organized at a minimum of expense, and would serve the double purpose of encouraging the growth of large