of their own. Modern Zionism, confining itself strictly to the pursuit of political and economic aims, has no such Utopia in mind. It does not care for an amalgamation of religions, and predicts a religious renascence of Judaism as a natural result of national unification.
Furthermore, with Fraenkel, sovereign rights are indispensable. He needs $200,-000,000 to realize his plan. Modern Zionism rests content with the establishment of a homestead legally secured —which greatly reduces the requisite sum.
In one particular both Fraenkel and modern Zionism were mistaken: Both believed it was easy to raise the necessary money; bitter experience has shown the error of this.
About the personality of Fraenkel I could gather scanty and disconnected details.
In 1853, it seems, he was employed as a typesetter with Berger-Levault; not so in 1868, the year of his interesting publication. It appears that he lived in Strassburg before the war, and subsequently removed to Paris.
He is probably the author of a minor article in the Archives Israelites on a certain Parisian epitaph of historical interest.
I had occasion to talk to several persons who knew Fraenkel during his Strassburg residence. They all describe him as an able man of lovable traits of character; of his writings, they knew nothing.
The historic pamphlet on the re-establishment of the Jewish nation was printed at the author's own expense. Berger-Levault, who seem to have been wise in their generation, took only a few copies on commission.
The pamphlet, despite its brilliancy of thought and its elegant diction, found only a few readers; the contemporary press took no notice of it whatever.
It could not interest the author's own generation. The Jews of his times were assimilators and too eager to identify themselves with their hosts.
Anyone opposing assimilation was looked upon as a marplot and a stumbling block in the path of what was supposed to be natural evolution. Anyone pleading Jewish nationalism was considered a dreamer of dreams.
The assimilators, looking upon Jewish national decomposition as a sign of progress, undoubtedly considered Fraenkel a reactionary.
They neither did, nor could they understand him. A controversy was adjudged useless; his pamphlet, without a conspiracy of silence fell still-born from the press. The work of Fraenkel left no traces until Herzel and Nordau pointed out the better way. But the Alsation Zionism will keep green the plous memory of the man who pre-divined our Jewish national future, when pondering upon the glories of the past.