The Maccabaean · Vol. XXI, No. 11 · May 1912
296printed page
scan 6 of 30

Territorialism. The world must be taught that the Jew must be given the same right as his fellow-citizen, the right to rear his family, the right to find his happiness under whatever sky or in whatever clime he may choose. We have lived in this country for over 1,000 years. Because we worship God in a different language, and because the tenets of our faith differ from those of the established religion, that is no reason why we are aliens. Will the time never come when the Jews of Roumania, Russia and Galicia will enjoy civil and religious liberty? America has set an example by abrogating the commercial treaty with Russia. We took care not to make this a Jewish question; we made it an American question."

He speaks of the problem of the "Jew." It is not the problem of the Jew, but of the Jewish people. If emigration of every sort will not solve the problem, of course then the problem must be solved in the lands of persecution. Then what does Mr. Solomons propose? He still wishes to teach the world that the Jewish people is entitled to human rights. But hasn't the German reform movement been teaching that, and has anti-Semitism in Germany decreased? Does Mr. Solomons believe that the problem really cannot be solved by emigration? Then why are the European Jewish leaders interested in the migration of Jews from Russia? Is it not a bit impolite for Mr. Solomons to speak in this vein in England of to-day?

The Rabbinical Convention.

A SUCCESSFUL convention of the Central Conference of American Rabbis was held last month in Baltimore. A large amount of routine business was transacted, a number of scholarly papers were read, and in a general way the Conference is registered as a success—among the rabbis themselves and in the slow-pulsed Jewish public opinion, which, with regard to the Conference, scarcely beats at all. The Conference has finally decided to have a revision of its Union Prayer Book for reasons of style only, according to the President's suggestion. It may be said that seldom has a Conference had the tonic pleasure of listening to a presidential message of such clearness of thought and vigor of expression as was presented by Dr. Samuel Schulman.

But aside from its condemnation of Christian Science—a work of almost comical irrelevancy—the Conference took occasion once more to air its views on nationalism and adopted a resolution which was aimed against Zionism and political clubs, but which came out of the composing-room as an attack upon any organization of Jews not based on religious tenets. The resolution read as follows: "Inasmuch as we are unqualifiedly committed to the total separation of Church and State, we discountenance any movement toward organizing Jewish communities on other than the religious basis, which would violate this principle and tend to create the impression that the Jews are an imperium in imperio." Dr. David Philipson, reviewing the Conference, takes it for granted that this gathering of rabbis has re-affirmed its opposition to Zionism. He shows himself little of a diplomat or of a leader by making any such statements, for it is a known fact that a large proportion of the members of the Conference are either Zionists or of the opinion that the Conference should be neutral to Zionism and its manifestations. At any rate we may with propriety point to the fact that Dr. Schulman in his presidential message said: "It was certainly a great joy to all of us to note that many American rabbis, members of this Conference, were helpful to the recent visitor to our country on behalf of Jewish education in Palestine." The allusion was to Dr. Benzion Mossinsohn. No one protested against this statement.

The New York Kehillah Convention.

THE convention of the New York Kehillah, held on April 28, upheld the Bureau of Education, and voted its confidence in Dr. Benderly, director of the Bureau. This vote of confidence came after a set debate of over three hours. The debate brought out the fact that the opposition to the Bureau had "no case." Its criticisms of Dr. Benderly were unworthy of serious consideration. As a matter of course, the motion of confidence in the Bureau had to be adopted. But the Kehillah is on the wrong tack if it believes that the defeat of the opposition to Dr. Benderly means that the Jewish community is satisfied with the work of the Bureau. There are strong and convincing reasons for saying that the relations of the Bureau of Edu-