The Maccabaean · Vol. XXI, No. 11 · May 1912
302printed page
scan 12 of 30
302
THE MACCABÆAN

sentative" Jews in America. I like to quote the saying of a young Russian friend of mine: "When I was in Russia I was a Jew. Now I am an American." My friend was right. One cannot easily be a consistent Jew, whether reform or Orthodox, and yet be truly an American in all that the word implies and signifies. Hence we are often accused of clannishness, and the charge is laid against us that we are unable or unwilling to wholly lose ourselves in the community around us. We are always jealously guarding our separate Jewishness, striving to justify and define it by enforced observance, or else we drift helplessly along, caught in popular currents, and our small and inconsequent Jewishness disappears, with nothing left to take its place. Not so with Zionism, however. On the contrary, we can, and we ought to be, Zionists in America, because, like Americanism, Zionism is the democratization of our people, wherein all are made one and equal—all nationalities and all shades of belief, conservative, liberal, agnostic, atheistic (if there be any such), all are welcome, and all hold equal rank among us. Sephardian can no longer hold themselves aloof as higher, holier, than the rest of us, and look down loftily upon Ashkenazim. Spanish Jews can no longer despise German Jews, nor German, Russian Jews, and so on all along the scale. All the wretched Jewish anti-Semitisms which are so much more contemptible than the Gentile anti-Semitism we so loudly decry and resent, must utterly disappear from among us when once we are fellow-Americans and fellow-Zionists.

We are not serving two masters, but one and the same glorious mistress—freedom—of soul and spirit; freedom from our own limitations and those imposed upon us by others.

There is still another reason why we should be Zionists in America. Zionism no longer asks, What has America to give me? But, what have I to give to America in return for what she has so generously given me, and what she gives to the world? The "modernized, occidentalized, liberalized" Judaism of which some of us may like to boast has nothing whatever to give that America does not already possess in larger, fuller measure herself; the very gift she has indeed bestowed upon us. It surely were fatuity on our part, no

less than foolish lack of originality to think we are offering her anything new. Zionism, on the contrary, has something different, something generic and of another type to give; the very thing perhaps that America needs, for we all know very well that there is a lack in our modern, Western American life; in spite of, or perhaps, because of its tremendous pitch, and onrush of irresistible activity, there is a lack of true dignity and repose. There is too much hurry and scurry and grab; too much headlong haste to carry off some of the prizes, to arrive to some glittering point of fancied eminence; too much bustle and barter, for things not quite worth the scramble. We need to sit still and alone more often, away from the clatter of the crowd and the market, in order to know the real values of life, the great truths that can only be known in the silence of lesser things. As the Bible says, "Be still and know that I am God." All the deep life of Nature is accomplished in silence, and in the great peace of sure and perfect fullfilment, unresting, but unhasting also, "the peace which passes our understanding." The whirlwind, the thunder, the earthquake are exceptional adjuncts, and serve but to enhance and to justify the silence. And I think I am not wrong in believing that this power and authority of silence, this repose of conviction, through which we feel ourselves related to things large and eternal, belong more to the East than to the West. The West has never originated any great religion. It has only adapted and elaborated theologies and systems of philosophy, fitting or misfitting them to Western forms and purposes. But, we Jews still carry in our hearts the divine spark—the day star of the Orient, unless, I may add, we have so wholly domesticated and occidentalized ourselves in the struggle to compete with our neighbors, as to barter away even this pearl of great price. But most of us have not done so foolishly. We still bear in our soul the soul of the desert—the wide, vast spaces, the great silence, the great solitude, the silent watches of the night under the calm, large stars of the East, "the flight of the alone to the Alone."

It is just this gift that America needs. Once again, let me repeat: The Message of Zionism is Peace —not the peace of a declining day—but the peace of the sunrise, the radiant dawn of a new light among men.