The Maccabaean · Vol. XXI, No. 10 · April 1912
268printed page
scan 8 of 32
260
THE MACCABÆAN

that they may be trusted to oppose crass brutality, may be taken for granted. We would not deny that Jews have had a great deal to do with the creation of public opinion here and elsewhere, and we know that Turkey appreciates this exhibition of our power over public opinion. At the same time, Jews in Italy, bound to the destiny of their government, have not been backward in presenting the other side, and although it is hard to muster up arguments favorable to Italy, it has been done on many occasions, and by Jews. It is said that the Jews of Tripoli have on several occasions demonstrated their attachment to Italian authority. As bearing upon Jewish interests, we unhesitatingly admit that our interests are with Turkey, and the fact that Italian pretensions are in the wrong gives additional strength to those who are advocating the cessation of hostilities in Tripoli, and the submission of the controversy to arbiters. Turkey's rights have been too long ignored. It has been treated too long as a football in the interests of various European powers. The time has come for Turkey to be accorded the same treatment that is accorded to other countries that are engaged in establishing order and representative government in their midst.

A Harvard Professor on Jewish State.

WHENEVER a non-Jew approaches the Jewish question and discusses Zionism, his reasoning inevitably brings him to the acceptance of the principles underlying the Zionist movement. It is only Jews who enter the arena with prejudiced eyes who find a variety of irreconcilable arguments against our program. Prof. Thomas A. Carver, of Harvard University, speaking before the Harvard Zionist Society recently spoke on the desirability of a Jewish state. He assumed that the maintenance of the Jewish identity was desirable. There are two ways only in which the Jewish race may be preserved, he said. One way is that the Jews should form a distinct layer of the population in every country, as it appears they do to-day; the other way is by segregation in a territory of their own. Professor Carver thought that the latter way was by far the more desirable, and chiefly for three reasons. First,

territorial segregation is the only way to avoid anti-Semitism. Anti-Semitism is not anything peculiar or abnormal in the present state of the Jews. Anti-Semitism is the result of the social war that developes between races living together but not amalgamating, competing with each other for the limited supply of that which the people of the different races all want, and is bound to arise with antagonism and prejudice. If there are only a few of a different race in the community, those few may be often respected and admired, and their successes regarded with approval. But when the few become many, by immigration, all of them together are considered, not so much individually, but as a body, alien and unwelcome. (This is one of the premises of Herzl's program) It is not a question of superiority or inferiority of race. The Jews are not the only people to suffer from this natural antagonism. With the increase of the numbers of Jews in this country, there is bound to increase, however much we regret it, the anti-Jewish feeling. Probably it will never express itself in the form of pogroms, as in Russia; yet Professor Carver expressed a fear. The second reason why the territorial segregation would be desirable is that it would enable the Jews to leave off specializing in certain industries and activities, as they have been forced to do by historic national economy, and lead a harmonious national life. This would be an advantage not only to the Jews themselves, but for civilization. The third reason for territorial segregation is not so palpable as the previous two, yet none the less important for that. A spot of the earth that the Jews could call their own, a flag, their own mode of life, could afford them, as such things afford other peoples, a great intellectual and spiritual satisfaction, and might call forth a valuable national culture.

Fagin in New York.

A REVIVAL of Dickens' "Oliver Twist" occupies a theatre in New York. It is attracting considerable attention and threatens to run far into the summer. The play is the version of the novel used in London by Beerhohm Tree, and reflects the atmosphere of the original to a greater extent than other adaptations have done. Probably