The Maccabaean · Vol. XXI, No. 10 · April 1912
265printed page
scan 5 of 32

glance at the names of the members who expressed an intention to be present at the Conference shows that not less than ten percent. are avowed Zionists. The actual number of Rabbis who are Zionists, of course, it would be impossible to estimate. At any rate, we do not appreciate the reasons given by this ten per cent. of Zionist Rabbis for remaining silent on the question of Zionism. It is true that resolutions of the Conference are not binding upon all its members. But if resolutions are not binding, what the Conference does in the way of propagating ideas that are in opposition to Zionism is stultifying to those rabbis who are Zionists. The Union Prayer Book is a publication issued by the Conference. Its agents are engaged in selling that book, from which all reference to Zionism has been expurgated. The expurgation of the Siddur was the work of the Conference. The Conference is not neutral to Zionism; it is opposed to it, and its opposition takes practical form. Its field agent does not preach a doctrine of Judaism which excludes disapproval of Zionism. He represents a view which denies that the Jews are anything else but a religious denomination. These two instances may be taken as evidence of the commitment of the Conference to an anti-Zionist platform, and Dr. David Philipson, whose antagonism to Zionism is well-known, and whose methods are always dignified and fair, insists that the resolutions adopted by the Conference years ago, never having been repealed, stand as the expression of the Conference's position on Zionism. Should not the Conference, if it is neutral to Zionism, at least repeal these resolutions? Should not the Zionist reform rabbis insist upon their repeal?

The Source of Montefiore's Inspiration.

In a review of Claude G. Montefiore's "Outlines of Liberal Judaism." Dr. Joseph Jacobs, traces the source of his inspiration to Prof. Jowett, who taught Greek in Oxford University, and was a forceful exponent of Broad Church theories. Writing of Mr. Montefiore's book in The American Hebrew, Dr. Jacobs says: "One of the most interesting of Mr. Montefiore's chapters is that dealing with

nation and the race, in which he discusses, rather inadequately, the opposition of Libera] Judaism to Zionism. The last chapters of Mr. Montefiore’s book will, perhaps, be the ones most discussed, since in them he deals with his view of the relation between Judaism and Christianity. Here, while Mir. Montefiore lays stress upon the opposition which Judaism makes to any form of the doctrine of Incarnation, he yet grants a certain validity to the Christian doctrine of justification by faith as opposed to the Jewish view of justification by works. His treatment in the last chapter on the Jewish attitude towards Jesus is by no means clear; he contends, as he has done before. that there are certain aspects of the teachings of Jesus and Paul which might be adopted by the Jews, but he fails to state exactly what they are and still lays stress upon the notion of faith or belief as fundamental even in Liberal Judaism. Here we can trace the influence of Jowett and, in general, of the Christian atmosphere in which Mr. Montefiore thas been mainly surrounded. Throughout his book he has been concerned with doctrines and with theories and beliefs, while the forms and ceremonies in which such beliefs are expressed in a historic religion receive but scant notice. The Broad Church, of which Jowett was the most eminent representative. made the same mistake in dealing with Anglican Christianity and, for that reason, ultimately failed. The older Liberals were individualists and left altogether out of account the social and historic elements in man’s mind in their conceptions of both Church and State. Mr. Montefiore, adogting this now antiquated attitude, leaves almost entirely out of account the communion of the Jew with the Israel of the past, of the present. and of the future. This makes his treatment in the latter part of his book one-sided and causes him to leave out of account the most powerful influence in the Jewish mind.”

The Tragic Life of a Hebrew Poet.

A SELECTION of the Hebrew poems of Ascher Shapiro, who was converted to Christianity in Russia, and who suffered for it all his life, has been published by the Tuchiya publishing house. Shapiro fell