The Maccabaean · Vol. XXI, No. 10 · April 1912
281printed page
scan 21 of 32
THE MACCABAEAN
281

that sort of freedom of speech which descends to personalities. We hope that Mr. Fredman and others whom he represents will appreciate the fact that THE MACCABAEAN aims to comment upon incidents of Jewish life without haste and with due respect for the opinions of those who disagree with it. The responsibility rests with THE MACCABAEAN and THE MACCABAEAN is able to defend any of its opinions. Our correspondent is needlessly alarmed. He is also needlessly offended. What was said with regard to the relative values of Zionism and of the Jewish religion, in the form which it has been adopted in America and in other lands where the Jews have gone forth from their ghettos, has been said before. To become a mass-movement that will appeal to all Jews, Zionism had to speak of Jewish life as embracing all phenomena of Jewish life, in which religion occupies a large part. To speak of the Jewish religion as only a part of the Jewish life does not imply insult or derogation to the Jewish religion. THE MACCABAEAN and many of Dr. Magnes' friends have felt that his place was not in the rabbinate. Judge Mayer Sulzberger is a leader of Jewish causes in America. Mr. Louis Marshall is another. Mr. Jacob H. Schiff is a third. Judge Julian W. Mack is a fourth. To speak of these gentlemen as having interests that are larger than the interests of any synagogue, no matter how influential that synagogue may be, is not to minimize the value of the synagogue in the economy of Jewish life. The function of the rabbi, as it has developed here, presupposes attention to the needs of a congregation, constant study of religious problems of its worshippers, and a devotion to those forms of social life that connect with religious ceremonies or services. The synagogue was the center of Jewish life, and it gathered under its roof all that there was of Jewish life. But we are living in a time of transition. The synagogue has been reduced in value. Many of us may deplore the fact, but it is a fact nevertheless, and as Zionists, engaged in the task of arousing the Jewish people as a whole to the need of effort for the preservation of the Jewish people and the safeguarding of its future, it is our duty to attract to our banner Jews who worship and those who do not, Jews who

are relate! to their people completely and those who are held only by slender threads. Necessarily, then, we say that Zionism is a concept larger than the concept Jewish rehgion, and one who goes out of the profession of rabbi, intending to devote himself to Jewish education, the spread of a knowledge of Hebrew, the defense of Jewish interests, political, economic, cultural, ete, goes from the linuted to a much larger field) This, the editorial in) question amed to say. Dr. Maenes’ experiences with three different congregations amply demonstrated the fact that he is not the man to concentrate upon the problems of congregational life. The effort made by him to accomplish this fact resulted in waste of energy. It is our opinion that had he based his activities upon a purely Zionistic platform, refusing to be swerved from his course of gaining adherents to the movement toward Palestine, the years he has spent with the various congregations would have born fruit of greater value to Zionism. He felt, however, that by swerving from the straight course he was of greater benefit to our cause. He is now on the road to recovery from this error. As the head of the Kehillah, with its many problems, he will be freer to give more time and thought to those immediate interests with which we are concerned. At any rate, in venturing the opinion that his stepping out of the rabbinate was a step in the direction of a less restricted usefulness and a token of a further liberation in order that he may take up his position in the Zionist movement, we -were not going bevond the expression of a Zionist hope. Mr. Fredman may not be in agreement with what was said, but a distorted interpretation of the editorial with an argument that has little relevancy is no way of expressing that disagreement. —FEditors THe MaAccABAEAN,

—Editors THE MACCABAEAN.

A Note on THE MACCABAEAN.

THE MACCABAEAN is pleased to announce that Mr. Max J. Herzberg, Mr. Frank Schechter and Miss Sarah Kussy have joined its staff. Mr. Isidore Bloom has undertaken the business management of the magazine. With this added strength, our readers may look forward to increased improvement in our publication.