The Maccabaean · Vol. XXI, No. 10 · April 1912
272printed page
scan 12 of 32
Facsimile · scan 12 of 32
Scan of p. 272
Text · transcribed from the scan

des a great critic. Zahmenhoff invented a universal language. Asher Ginsberg reminds us that the Jewish sculptor Anatokolsky chose Russian, rather than Jewish subjects. So too the many scientists that are going forth from Jewry to-day, from the very nature of the case, could not give a Jewish character to a general discovery in astronomy or medicine. All such culture of Jews, but not Jewish culture—both extremes—looking exclusively to a Jewish circle and ignoring the world or ignoring Jewish association and appealing to the world are equally unfortunate for our cause. I believe in Jewish culture; but I think the time has come when the world in general should be made sharers in Jewish product. Too long have we hidden our light behind a bushel. Too long has Jewish genius languished in the ghetto or restricted itself to tongues unread by the world. Mr. Zangwill was among the first to make pictures of Jewish life subjects of general interest. The new school of Jewish art should choose its themes from the rich storehouse of Israel's heroism and display them in the galleries of the nations. It is time that they should know we are not only concerned in trade; that a Jewish drama, a Jewish poetry and a Jewish philosophy are being produced from the ghettos, which deserve place in the schools and in the universities at large.

It may be said that this awakening of the Jewish consciousness need hardly be given the distinctive label of "cultural Zionism." The term Jewish is all-sufficient and comprehensive. It is not a new doctrine that any one would assail. It surely must immediately meet the indorsement of all who are Jewish enough to be concerned in a higher welfare of the Jew. But we need not quarrel about terms. It is a refreshing contrast, indeed, from those in our midst who are leading prosaic, superficial, vacuous, tawdry, and indulgent lives. These indeed are the ones who can only be negatively described as "out of Egypt." They belong neither to the ghetto, nor to Zion, nor to the Church. They have no goal. The political Zionist has at least a distinctive aim and the courage of his convictions.

I I I

Many Zionists are loyal Jews, and among them, are some of our very best.

But Zionism as such, is not necessarily religious. It has unconsciously transferred its central concern from Judaism to the Jew. Seemingly in the ghetto, the neonationalists may be further removed from it than any. Let us not confuse the tremendous influx of Jewish refugees as a revival of Judaism, though it may bring to the front more vividly the observance of Jewish ceremonial. Let us remember that cultural Zionism does not necessarily involve the culture of Judaism. It is a call of a return to Zion, but not necessarily the Zion "whence goeth forth the Law." Let us endorse a movement toward culture, but only as a means toward the religious end. As culture purely and secularly of the Jewish folk, it no more appeals to our conscience and our moral obligation than culture in general, in its broad and educative value. As an artistic, linguistic, or literary movement, we would have the right to choose classic, Teutonic or American culture. We know that many who are ardently Zionistic are not believers in the Jewish religion. It is almost a transfer from the worship of the God of Israel to the worship of Israel itself. We cannot consent to the change of our obligation from Judaism to Jewishness. Would not this be offering strange fire on the altar of sanctuary? The cultivation of Hebrew as a living language can meet with the disapproval of none. If it replaces Yiddish, the patois of the ghetto, as Asher Ginsberg hopes, it is a distinct good. But when so many of the young in homes where Hebrew instruction is given are becoming the prey of the missionaries, must we not direct our emphasis rather to the simple presentation of the cardinal principles of our faith, its poetic beauties, its moral imperatives, and its demand for social justice, that pervades not only its Prophets, but the Jews? We are facing an issue different from that ever presented before us—strenuous Jews, without Judaism.

Culture must be directed towards religious revival. Religion has always been our function, our excuse for being, the explanation of our survival. Some Zionists retort, "Shall we merely be a religious Community?" If we are really religious, they will not say merely. If we can develop an idealism that will make its influence felt in the world, becoming, so to speak,