The Maccabaean · Vol. XXI, No. 9 · March 1912
257printed page
scan 25 of 30

Prof. Sombart on Anti-Semitism

Professor Werner Sombart delivered a lecture on "Anti-Semitism and Judaism" before a very large audience in Berlin on Feb. 8. He said that he had been prompted in his choice of theme by the accusations that had been made that he was an anti-Semite, and by the warnings that had been circulated against attending his lectures. In Munich a Rabbi had actually delivered a warning against him from the pulpit. On the other hand, the anti-Semites had stigmatized him as a "Judenknecht." saturated with the Jewish spirit, and Professor Sombart read an entertaining extract from an anti-Semitic print, which sought to discover behind his lineaments and gestures a genuine son of Israel.

Turning from this personal aspect of the question, the lecturer said that anti-Semitism has existed ever since the Diaspora, and divided the history of the movement into three main periods—ancient, mediaeval and modern. He distinguished it from all other great conflicts in history in so far as he maintained that all other conflicts, such as wars of the Crusades, were caused by one of three vital interests: (a) national or racial, (b) economic and (c) religious; whereas anti-Semitism was aroused by a combination of all three factors.

Present-day anti-Semitism lacked the economic religious factor, which had characterized mediaeval anti-Semitism. but contained both the economic and the national or racial factors. In addition to these specific classes, Professor Sombart laid stress on the inherited aversion to the Jews which was found in circles that had never seen a Jew, that were not religious, and that had not suffered any economic injury through Jews.

He contended that all other arguments, such as the alleged inferiority of Jewish culture, were quite subsidiary, a man considered the Jews to be of inferior culture because he was an anti-Semite—he was not an anti-Semite because he considered them of inferior culture, and the same principle applied to the superstition about Jewish ritual murder.

Prof. Sombart then endeovored to deduce certain conclusions or “lessons.”

In the first place, he regarded anti-Semitism as an absolute necessity —it was conditioned by the very fact of the long existence of the Jewish people. Secondly, anti-Semitism would continue as far as one could foresee. Though religious antagonisms were weakening and economic conflicts might pass away, he believed the traditional aversion would still prevail, and he did not agree with Karl Marx that with the abolition of capital the Jewish question would disappear. Thirdly, the lecturer said that anti-Semitic parties were on the decline, because anti-Semitism had no specific programme, and therefore lacked a party-building character. In proof of this he instanced the anti-Semitic decline in the Reichstag elections.

116 nevertheless deprecated such severe denunciations of the movement as were contained in the utterance that anti-Semitism was a stain upon the century, though he agreed in condemning any anti-human or anti-moral form it might assume. In no other movement had there been so much venom and filth employed. In this respect, anti-Semitism surpassed socialism, for this is amovement againsta system, whereas the former was a movement against persons. Theoretically, said the lecturer, he regarded the fight against the Jews absolutely sterile and absurd. Nor did he perceive any useful purpose in the intellectual duel between protagonists of Semitic and Aryan culture as represented by Zollschan and Houston Chamberlain. As the Jews lived among non-Jews and would continue to do so, in the enjoyment of all rights, why should the non-Jews try to make clear to themselves why they hated the Jews?

The anti-Semites, indeed. realized that they could not achieve anything, and this accounted for the slow breaking-up of their party. One good effect of anti-Semitism, said Prof. Sombart, consisted in its promoting the national characteristics of the Jews as represented in the Zionist movement. In conclusion, he reverted to his own personal standpoint and said that he neither wished the Jews to be deprived of emancipation nor removed from their present condition, nor did he hate the Jews. At the same time he recognized that there were defects in the Jewish race as in any other race. In short, Prof. Som-