marise what the philosophical analysis of history and seaching study of the doctrine of heredity have elucidated with practical certainty. The law of the non-transmission of acquired characteristics, the law of the absolute permanence of specific character, may be treated to-day as disproved. From the point of view of science the idea of a particular quality in race psychology reMaining constant throughout history is entirely excluded. And, on the other hand, the inductive treatment of the philosophy of history demonstrates that there is not, and never has been, an essential psychical differentia of particular races, in the sense at any rate that all eninent Frenchmen must display themselves in esprit, all eminent Germans as poets and thinkers; that the distinctive capacity of the ancient Greeks was exclusively art: of the ancient Indians philosophy; of the Romans energy; of the Jews of to-day commercial talent, family affection, and the capacity for being socially destructive. It is not that these distinctive qualities do not exist. It would be senseless to deny that the Romans displayed themselves by their energy, the Greeks by their artistic sense, and that other peoples again are weak and lack energy; that the character of the Scandinavians is different from that of the Italians. But the reason why these peoples have at particular epochs manifested just these characteristics is not that they were originally endowed with them by some special benignant or malignant providence. The determining cause for it may be easily found in the external circumstances and in the historical and social environment of these peoples. It is impossible, too, that these characteristics could have remained for centuries quite unchanged and steadfast, and it is absurd to suppose that a different environment could not have produced their opposites, The productive qualities of different races are not constant; with any people at any particular epoch they depend not on the race, but on the environment at the time, plus the environment of former generations. That is the conclusion of scientific investigation into this question, of the laws of heredity and acquired character, and likewise of the results of historical inquiry. With the different stages of culture through which a people progresses, its psychology changes. It is the psychology of these
stages and not of race which is responsible for the spiritual condition of any people. The influence of the environment, however, may in certain cases be broken.
Nevertheless, it may be positively asserted that the cultural values of different peoples vary according to their race. This follows again with the like certainty from the laws of heredity as they are manifested in the examples of history. For its productive capacity, for its spiritual endowment, it is not immaterial from what race a people is sprung. The descendants of one race may be actually highly endowed, those of another much less gifted. And the explanation is not far to seek. Throughout organic nature each being has most thoroughly developed that organ which has been most used by it. What a man exercises grows. Whenever it was necessary for a species or race to develop the sharpness of the brain, whenever any species or race of its free will or of necessity was led to perfect itself in the direction of cerebral productiveness, then by a natural law the descendants of that race had a superiority over the descendants of other races. While the productice quality, as has been shown, depends on the environment, the quantitative element in spiritual capacities, the size of the endowment. and the intensity of the psychical life, in a word the productive quota depends not on the environment, but on the race, on the intensity of the intellectual activity of their ancestors.
But we are anticipating. The quota of endowment varies with every race, whatever be its intellectual stage. There is no particular gift belonging to one particular race. And in the face of this it seems more than strange to talk of the “cardinal and irreconcilable antithesis existing between the Aryan and the Semitic soul.” An error which has allowed countless generations to believe that to one group of peoples nobility of soul and depth of thought are denied, while to another group they belong by right of birth without their having to move a finger—such nonsense can only be surpassed by that other nonsense which for exactly a hundred years has been taken for granted by scholars and laymen, Jews and Christians, and the political consequences of which have been more widespread than any other—namely